News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Replace Skype with Discord for Better Audio Quality and W... by CharlesW on Sunday January 21, 2018 @12:28PM (#16198928)
This is a common way to record remote interviews (since the mid-1900s, I think), and is called a "multi-ender" (or "double-ender").[1]

They're straightforward to do manually. All parties participate in a recorded "1-2-3-clap" at the beginning and end of the call, and the claps are later used for sync.

There are also many "assisted" solutions, including Cast[2], Cleanfeed[3], Ringr[4], and Zencastr[5]. Some folks find them useful, but the additional dependency also means more things that can go wrong. Anybody using them has learned (or will learn) that they must record the live/VoIP portion of the call as well, as backup.

[1] Wikipedia calls this a "phone-sync" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phone-sync), which is not a term I've ever heard people actually use.

[2] https://tryca.st/ [3] http://cleanfeed.net/ [4] https://www.ringr.com/ [5] https://zencastr.com/

Re:Replace Skype with Discord for Better Audio Quality and W... by mseebach on Sunday January 21, 2018 @12:36PM (#16198984)
Excellent, I'm happy (and feel validated) that this exists.

As this would replace Skype (or whatever conferencing tool you're using), it's not really an additional dependency, is it?

Re:Replace Skype with Discord for Better Audio Quality and W... by CharlesW on Sunday January 21, 2018 @01:09PM (#16199145)
> As this would replace Skype (or whatever conferencing tool you're using), it's not really an additional dependency, is it?

It is in the sense that those solutions are not only replacing the realtime part of the call, but additionally must do separate source-quality call recording and post-call file transfer sessions for each participant.

I've lost calls (or would have, if I hadn't recorded the realtime part) with more than one of those solutions because of unrecoverable errors on participants' sides. I'm reluctant to name them since (1) they in turn depend on browsers and their WebRTC implementations, and (2) in my experience different podcasters will swear by and swear at the same solution.

Here's how I'd order the reliability of common remote recording scenarios, from most to least reliable:

(1) Landline-to-landline

(2) Landline-to-mobile or mobile-to-mobile

(3) SkypeOut-to-landline/mobile

(4) VoIP-to-VoIP — Skype, Discord, whatever.

(5) Manual multi-ender — Can be done very reliably if remote participants are reasonably comfortable with recording audio. Still requires a POTS, mobile, or VoIP call for the realtime part.

(6) Assisted multi-ender solutions — Generally way less reliable than manual multi-enders. In my experience and from talking with other podcasters, expect 1/20 calls to fail.