News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by taneq on Sunday January 21, 2018 @02:44AM (#16197228)
So closed loop control qualifies a machine as a robot? I'd think it also needs some degree of generality, a robot arm can be reprogrammed for different tasks but something like a VSD cannot.
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by kilpikaarna on Sunday January 21, 2018 @04:57AM (#16197474)
Yup, generality and reprogrammability would be my criterion as well. As for closed loop control, well maybe? Just about everything meant for industry uses servos, so there's a closed loop for positioning, but it won't necessarily know anything about the work itself.

What's a VSD in this case? Variable Speed Drive?

Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by taneq on Sunday January 21, 2018 @07:50PM (#16201048)
Yeah, sorry - VSD = variable speed drive. They often have a built-in PID controller which takes an analog input and controls the motor speed accordingly, so for example you can run drive a pump at the required speed to produce a required flow rate.
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by dekhn on Sunday January 21, 2018 @10:44AM (#16198447)
Yes, I'd say that a the essence of a robot is that it uses sensors to adjust its output actuators to achieve a goal.
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by AlotOfReading on Sunday January 21, 2018 @12:32PM (#16198943)
The bread and butter of the industrial robotics industry is SCARA machines for pick 'n place. These commonly don't have any sensors beyond a few rotary encoders and motor feedback. They're just moving between preprogrammed points. It's hard to make a simple definition that includes everything.
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by dekhn on Sunday January 21, 2018 @01:55PM (#16199370)
"These commonly don't have any sensors beyond a few rotary encoders and motor feedback."

you contradicted your own point. Those are sensors. Without them the P&P wouldn't be able to do its job.

Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by AlotOfReading on Sunday January 21, 2018 @02:10PM (#16199434)
I could take the encoders out and the robot would work fine. Its position would just grow increasingly inaccurate over time and make the production line more fragile. It would also make writing the pick n place code a bit of a pain for several reasons, but they're not fundamental to the design.
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by gugagore on Sunday January 21, 2018 @03:23PM (#16199783)
I mean... the robot would decidedly not work fine without joint encoders, on any timescale relevant to the task. You likely could not accomplish one pick/place operation. You need the position feedback because you don't have a good enough model of the motors (and everything) to do feedforward control alone. So I'd say position feedback is pretty fundamental to the design. (If you have stepper motors, then okay, you do have a good enough model of the motors.)

I think I agree with your point at large, though, that the "proprioceptive" sensors of the robot don't have anything to do with the environment the robot is in, or the task at hand.

But now what about an air conditioner with a thermostat? That's got a sensor and an actuator and the sensor in this case really is fundamental to the task at hand.

Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by dekhn on Sunday January 21, 2018 @07:17PM (#16200917)
a thermostat, under my definition would indeed be a robot- although a fairly boring one since it doesn't move itself, just modulate room temperature.
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by taneq on Sunday January 21, 2018 @07:52PM (#16201055)
A toilet cistern would also qualify. (And in fact, while I wouldn't deem it a robot, I often use this as the simplest possible control system example.)
Re:I am a roboticist in a cheese factory by dekhn on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:07AM (#16205414)
nope, encoders are definitely fundamental. You cannot give a DC (brushed or not) motor voltage and have it turn a fixed distance. The closest thing is steppers, but once they stall, you've lost feedback and positioning information.