News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A smartphone retrospective by kenjackson on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:14AM (#1619668)
This article is wrong on multiple counts: 1) The iPhone didn't take off because it had no keyboard. It took off because it it had a decent web-browser. 2) Smartphones were a niche device in 2007. And generally were considered products that were severely lacking. The WinMo UI was considered a dog before the iPhone ever appeared. 3) Laptops aren't a niche product and generally aren't considered dogs. In general no one is looking for a laptop replacement, even amoung those that bought iPads.
Re:A smartphone retrospective by nanairo on Friday August 20, 2010 @06:48AM (#1620037)
To answer your three points:

1) Hindsight is always 20/20 right? People were predicting that the no keyboard thing was such a deal breaker than together with the no replaceable battery, it would make the iPhone a failure.

Obviously nobody here it's arguing that the iPhone is better because it doesn't have a keyboard: hey, if you could have your cake and eat it too, why not? But the point is that you need to make compromises, and by removing the keyboard Apple bet that the inconvenience was going to be more than made up by the advantages. Apparently they were right.

2) Yes, they were considered to be lacking though not as much as you think. In fact, many people complained about the iPhone because it couldn't do everything their smartphone could. Also knowing you have a problem, and knowing how to solve it are two hugely different things.

3) The point was about netbooks. Many people bought them as a secondary computer, to carry around, browse the web, etc. The iPad may or may not be a netbook replacement, but it is not being considered as a replacement for your main computer.

Apple had the balls to take a bet (as did Asus with the original netbook, imho) and won. Now suddenly it was obvious, not a big deal, etc.. etc...

Re:A smartphone retrospective by kenjackson on Friday August 20, 2010 @10:58AM (#1620548)
I disagree with your answers, but maybe in subtle ways.

1) The no keyboard thing was a deal breaker. But Apple did something no one had seen before. They introduced an exceptionally good onscreen keyboard. Miles ahead of the competition. They insight Apple had wasn't so much that we could just get rid of keyboards. It was that they could create a decent onscreen keyboard experience. To me, that is fundamentally different.

Replaceable battery? The only people who cared about that are pundits who have to nitpick about everything. How many people do you know that have a backup battery. I think I literally know nobody who does.

2) My point with #2 was that smartphones as devices were considered to be extremely flawed. Satisfaction with their smartphone was very low. This would make it easy for a better device to effectively change the whole landscape as no one really had a high satisfaction device.

3) OK, I probably just read netbook as laptop.

I do think you underestimate how big of a deal it is/was. Apple revolutionized the smartphone industry. My argument against the article is I think they did it via software, not by form factor.

Re:A smartphone retrospective by nanairo on Friday August 20, 2010 @11:22AM (#1620628)
Yeah, I think we kind of agree.

Re: #1 personally I think the reason why Apple could make a good onscreen keyboard is because they tried, and tried hard. I don't think there was any secret sauce: it's kind of the only thing you can do if you decided to go full screen

As for replaceable batteries I am with you... though when you read these sites it seems like everybody does mind.

As for point #2 I think the point the author was making is along your same lines. Just that he feels netbooks have also got very poor satisfaction rates (and I actually think studies have shown that, unless you really know what you are getting or are a geek).

As for hardware vs. software, I agree the secret sauce of Apple is in the software, but they also have a solid hardware, and in the hardware they often need to take the tough choices that others don't dare take.

Re:A smartphone retrospective by ecuzzillo on Friday August 20, 2010 @04:23AM (#1619844)
1) Do you really think the web browser was the only reason the iPhone took off? There were no other ways it failed to suck that all previous phones had sucked?

2) Actually, the pattern fits better if you compare smartphones before 2007 to tablets before the iPad. In both cases, the category contained shitty products that relatively few people used. In both cases, Apple got a bunch of different things right that made the entire category suddenly seem like it wasn't a bad idea anymore.

3) The comparison in TFA was to netbooks, not laptops. Netbooks were not fantastically widely used, and they did have problems.

Re:A smartphone retrospective by pornel on Friday August 20, 2010 @05:08AM (#1619901)
Web browser was usable because phone had large touchscreen, because there was no keyboard taking the real estate.

Opera Mobile (not Mini) was technically more than decent before Safari, but browsing experience was poor on smaller screens and keypads.

Re:A smartphone retrospective by dagw on Friday August 20, 2010 @08:52AM (#1620232)
There had been phones before the iPhone with large touch screens and no keyboards, and they all had shitty web browsing. Apple got it right because they where the first company to consider web browsing a first class integrated feature, as important as phone calls and text messaging, and not some minor add on to be fobbed off to some third party developer.
Re:A smartphone retrospective by pornel on Friday August 20, 2010 @11:18AM (#1620611)
Most (if not all) of those large-touchscreen phones had Windows Mobile on it, which was absolutely dreadful. There was no flick-to-scroll. You had to use stylus to grab 3px-wide scrollbar.

I think the problem wasn't that manufacturers didn't take browsing seriously (Opera is keen to work closely with manufacturers), but that they didn't take touchscreens seriously.