News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by adventured on Saturday January 20, 2018 @04:16PM (#16195465)
> How much longer can Intel keep holding on? Do they have an ace they've been hiding?

They do have an ace. $17 billion in operating income the prior four quarters. And about $17 billion in cash on hand.

Who knows if they'll put it to appropriate use to recover from their present mess. They very clearly have the resources to do so. Intel's $17 billion in operating income is over 4x the revenue of AMD, and 2x the revenue of nVidia. It's a pretty fantastical premise to be already counting Intel out, they've recovered from dramatically worse business situations in their past.

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by Iwan-Zotow on Saturday January 20, 2018 @04:46PM (#16195583)
They had $XX billions in income, and were Nx the revenue of AMD for the last 5 years - and, frankly, nothing spectacular/interesting to show. Some arch tweaking, process improvements, that's about it
Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by adventured on Saturday January 20, 2018 @05:00PM (#16195653)
Under your premise of prior situations predicting future actions, Microsoft should be collapsing about right now as Windows fades. IBM should not exist at all, the largest US corporate loss in history (at the time) that they produced in 1992 should have spelled their nearing end, with them fading into oblivion. Oracle should have died in the software wars, they survived several bet the ranch situations.

You know what was missing the last five years for Intel? Desperation. The need to fight back from a situation that threatens their well-being. They've done it before, usually when they were put in a desperate situation. That's also typical of human behavior in general (which is where the corporate behavior derives from).

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by Fnoord on Sunday January 21, 2018 @04:46AM (#16197458)
> Microsoft should be collapsing about right now as Windows fades.

Microsoft has been reinventing themselves; partly successfully, partly failing (Windows Phone / Nokia acquisition was arguably a recent example of a failure in this regard). Windows and Office are still the primary income for Microsoft, but cloud has gained traction, percentage-wise. Xbox is profitable (it wasn't for a long time). The Surface line is another example of Microsoft reinventing themselves.

> IBM should not exist at all

IBM has been relatively marginalised, and could've been so much more rich if the IBM-PC didn't backfire them with the clones getting popular, plus them getting tricked by Bill Gates with MSDOS and Windows (the failure to collaborate with Microsoft on OS/2). But as the B in IBM suggests, IBM never cared much about the consumer space.

Note, I'm not sure about POWER, how competitive that is with Intel's high-end products. Perhaps someone can comment on that.

I think what a company like Intel needs (or any company, really) is direct competition. Ie they need AMD. The competition with ARM and such is far more vague, less opaque. To be fair, Intel did try to compete on low end, with Atom. I remember they were busy with Moblin/MeeGo in the mid '00s. Never took off AFAIK.

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by Iwan-Zotow on Saturday January 20, 2018 @08:53PM (#16196475)
well, that is true, but

- they need to capture/create product niche with volume of sales in XX billions per quarter, otherwise it is not worth the effort

- in their traditional niche they have 90+%, the only way is down, basically

we'll see, but signs are not good. F.e., this idiot (https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/01/19/intel-corps-upcomi...) is hyping some 6/12 cores notebook CPU, while for any reasonable analyst this should be sign of desperation - Intel does NOT KNOW WHAT TO DO WITH SILICONE, so it's just slapping more cores together

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by jacquesm on Saturday January 20, 2018 @04:46PM (#16195586)
> they've recovered from dramatically worse business situations in their past.

Such as?

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by adventured on Saturday January 20, 2018 @05:12PM (#16195700)
They abandoned their primary business in memory chips, it was eroding out from under them rapidly (Japanese dumping, tanked their margins and was quickly slashing their share of the market). They bet the company on switching focus instead to the microprocessor business, per Moore & Grove (they both recount the story in various ways in interviews). Had they not done so, Intel would have likely gone out of business.

https://www.realworldtech.com/intel-dram/

Here's a pretty good cover of it from 2012 by NPR, interviewing Grove, in a series they did:

https://www.npr.org/2012/04/06/150057676/intel-legends-moore...

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by jacquesm on Saturday January 20, 2018 @06:20PM (#16195981)
Well, then they still had alternatives. There is not much in terms of alternatives for a broken reputation. Intel's management of this particular crisis hurts them precisely in the one place where they can not afford it.
Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by nickpsecurity on Saturday January 20, 2018 @06:24PM (#16195989)
Three, prior attempts at better CPU's plus one bug if we just go by the numbers. BiiN alone lost at least $300 million. They had to do a straight-up recall over the FDIV at a cost of who knows how many millions. Then, they and HP spent at least half a billion on Itanium over time. So, yeah, they've had some rough times with reactions or losses that are way worse than I've seen so far with this with some microcode updates and bad press. It certainly could get worse but not as bad yet.

Aside from those, I added a link to Intel i960 that spun out of the BiiN project since it was a nice, little RISC that you might like. It had object-based security and fault-tolerance built into it. There was still potential for reviving that before RISC-V ecosystem, CHERI, and so on obsoleted it. Too bad.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BiiN

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentium_FDIV_bug

https://www.wired.com/2012/02/hp-itanium/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_i960

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by serf on Saturday January 20, 2018 @05:02PM (#16195660)
It remains to be seen what the business impact of this latest fiasco is, but PR is easier to deal with than the physical recalls experienced with the FDIV bug or the intel SSDs a few years back.

This situation may become worse for them over time due to the attitudes of their partners in response to this fiasco, but as it stands (AT THIS POINT IN TIME) I think the FDIV bug was probably worse financially.

That said : I hope it hurts them just to help turn the industry away from such single-vendor dependence.

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by jacquesm on Saturday January 20, 2018 @06:36PM (#16196038)
> with the FDIV bug or the intel SSDs a few years back.

I lived through both of those, they did not come even close to the sense of brand damage that I have right now regarding how I personally perceive Intel, they have mis-handled this from day #1 and they are not doing much better than when it started.

Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by elihu on Saturday January 20, 2018 @09:23PM (#16196555)
There was that time they went all-in on Rambus, and then their supplier couldn't keep up with demand. That gave AMD a big opening that they took full advantage of.
Re:Intel Has a Big Problem by lmm on Saturday January 20, 2018 @06:47PM (#16196092)
They were further behind AMD in the P3/P4 days, and especially in the early days of 64-bit.