News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by hinkley on Friday January 19, 2018 @04:22PM (#16189982)
A fun dinner conversation is to ask people how we know what the crime rate is. "Crime is down." they say. Is it?

The crime rate is hinged on when a crime is detected. If I'm forgetful and you snag one of my power bricks I might just think I misplaced it or it got thrown away. If you've been embezzling and I can't tell yet I can't report it.

Crimes are being committed whether they get reported or not. We count on them having personality flaws like poor judgement and thrill seeking assuming they will eventually be caught. But if there are people who can go into a casino once a year and spend exactly $100, why can't there be criminals who steal $100 once a year and never get caught?

Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by PJDK on Friday January 19, 2018 @04:48PM (#16190146)
Off topic, but you get around this problem by surveying people's experience of crime, rather than look at police reports.

In the UK the survey is called the British Crime Survey and it's pretty robust in it's methodology (although not without criticisim). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_Survey_for_England_and_W...

Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by droopyEyelids on Friday January 19, 2018 @04:55PM (#16190195)
It's so off topic that you're not even talking about the same problem when you say "you get around this problem"

What a confusing post.

Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:39PM (#16191272)
> If you've been embezzling and I can't tell yet I can't report it

This is why murders are a gold standard for crime statistics. Most people agree murders are bad. And the rate at which murders become disappearances tends to be stable across time in a given society (but not between societies).

Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by hbosch on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:01PM (#16191369)
This is almost exactly the same philosophical discussion as "if a tree falls in the woods and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?", except with politics mixed in for extra spice.
Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by whatshisface on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:51PM (#16192127)
If your tree-death metric depended on the number of people who claimed to have heard a tree fall, tree deaths would appear to increase with greater numbers of hikers. Statistical polution is far from a purely philosophical issue...
Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by verylittlemeat on Friday January 19, 2018 @04:57PM (#16190215)
I really don't see this as anything other than a gotcha argument and I feel bad for anyone you tried to use it on who couldn't defend themselves in the heat of the moment.

The crime rate is a known political tool that is actively manipulated for political gain (stop and frisk anyone?). Everyone knows that being "tough on crime" is moral statement not a statement of fact. Outside of crime averages that operate on a continuum the crime rate is so subjective as to almost be useless.

I would say "the crime rate is down" as an argument is roughly equivalent to believing that any given president has an impact on the DJIA. Look at the cover of the NYPOST yesterday[0]. Attributing a president who has been in office for a year with anything having to do with the economy is almost always untrue [1]. In fact, if anything it's more likely that Trump is benefiting from the policies of his predecessor.

So in conclusion the "crime rate" is never up or down, it's just one tool in the political handbook to try and manipulate people with fear, uncertainty and doubt. As a basis of establishing policy it's almost always rhetoric. To further elaborate on your comment, it has less to do with when a crime is "detected" and more to do with what is a crime.

[0] https://i.imgur.com/uifDjWI.png

[1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/a-presidents-economic-d...

Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by hueving on Friday January 19, 2018 @05:44PM (#16190621)
Don't be intentionally obtuse. The point of the comparison was to highlight that lower detection of something doesn't mean less of it.
Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by verylittlemeat on Friday January 19, 2018 @05:56PM (#16190713)
It is a poor comparison. If I'm being intentionally obtuse then the parent is being willfully disingenuous.

Lower detection of crime doesn't mean less crime and higher detection of crime doesn't mean more crime.

The point is the crime rate as a tool to understand the effectiveness of law enforcement is useless.

This is a common problem I see all the time in "fact based" circles. People care more about the fact that the needle is moving rather than questioning if they're even measuring what they think they're measuring.

Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by hinkley on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:35PM (#16191253)
Context is everything.

    There's no reason to believe Slack would ever be able to detect someone exfiltrating chat logs. 
That's the context.

How about

    Crimes are being committed whether they get [identified] or not
Can we all relax now?
Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by verylittlemeat on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:28PM (#16191484)
It's basically advocating a conspiracy theory.

"Well, we can't PROVE someone isn't exfiltrating chat logs, therefore slack can't really be secure"

What is the value of this statement? How is it an indictment of slack's security?

From the podcast :

"Geoff also concludes that companies should encourage basic security hygiene rather than seek a silver bullet that does not exist."

So despite good law enforcement people get away with crimes. What exactly is the insight there? What is the actionable information for both slack and law enforcement of these "unknown unknowns?"

Re:How Slack Stays Secure During Hyper Growth by hueving on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:49PM (#16196778)
No, it's not advocating a conspiracy theory.

It's pointing out that you aren't very secure when you are operating in a model where it's even possible to leak all of your client records without even noticing.

Compare slack to something with actual end-to-end encryption and you'll start to see the difference.