Re:Seven Reasons Tech Start-Ups Are Setting Up Shop in New York
by whakojacko on Thursday August 19, 2010 @08:00PM
(#1619069)
Firstoff, Silicon Valley isn't a "town."
Secondly, I hate how articles (this one included) talk about new NY startups and how they are so different from ones in the Bay. While there is definitely some degree of truth to that, a lot of their examples focus on companies such as Tumblr and Foursquare, which seem like complete stereotypes of the current SV bubble: Consumer-oriented social platforms that are heavy on TechCrunch posts and light on revenue. Not that the the Bay Area doesn't have lots of those too, but if you want to talk about how "different" the NY startup scene is I think 4Sq is a terrible example. Gilt is a much better example.
I found this interesting, as my own echo-chamber-group-think radar is sometimes set off by things I hear coming out of the Valley scene. For example, some aspects of social media remind me of the original dotcom boom.
I don't live there though, so what does the HN crowd think about that, especially Valley denizens?
As a side note there are clear exceptions, like Ycominbator's diverse portfolio and wish list (http://ycombinator.com/ideas.html), among others.