News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by grandalf on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:42PM (#1618582)
Have you read The Virtue of Selfishness? I thought she did a decent job in justifying the first principles.

Considering that a lot of philosophers rely upon concepts like God, I think Rand's is a lot better developed than people give it credit for.

Rand's notion that humans have brains like animals have claws, and that brains are useful b/c they allow us reasoning, thus reasoning is good (to humans) like claws are good (to an animal)... I think that's a fairly persuasive claim, unless you would argue that human self-deception is more valuable than objectivity...

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:20PM (#1618700)
My point is that there are limits to the power of reason, which I never felt that Rand acknowledged. I freely admit that I only read her two major works (Atlas Shrugged and Fountainhead).

I would grant that you are correct that reasoning is a utilitarian good (for humans) just as claws are a utilitiarian good (for tigers), but it does not follow from this that reason can derive a notion of moral good.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by dk on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:20AM (#1619674)
I don't recall how she treated the fundamental questions of ethics in Atlas Shrugged but you might find her 'The Objectivist Ethics' interesting (http://www.aynrand.org/site/PageServer?pagename=ari_ayn_rand...). Here she presents her ideas on ethics fairly systematically, starting with questions like why man needs a code of ethics, what are values, and why does man need them.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by grandalf on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:29PM (#1618728)
Good point. I agree that her argument is not the strongest there, but I can't imagine another one that could be any more persuasive, especially if it involved the supernatural or tradition as many do.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by mike_organon on Friday August 20, 2010 @11:49AM (#1620700)
That's close, but you have to bring in the idea that the ultimate choice is life or death. Life (each individual's) is the standard of value and the starting point from which morality is derived. As long as someone chooses to continue to live (most of us do), they need to use the best means - that is, they should use reason, etc.