News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by maxxxxx on Thursday January 18, 2018 @08:42PM (#16183411)
Then they should be honest, explain the situation and torture people at home with their own specialists immediately and not fly to them to some country with questionable torturing skills.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by ImSkeptical on Thursday January 18, 2018 @09:25PM (#16183652)
I think you're confusing my position, and the contents of my comments, with something else.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by maxxxxx on Thursday January 18, 2018 @10:44PM (#16183989)
I think I understand your position. In the scenario you describe any kind of violence/torture needs to be done quickly to avert the situation. Otherwise it's too late. If the CIA renditions were based on something similar they shouldn't fly people to questionable countries but instead interrogate themselves quickly because times is of essence. Everything else would be irresponsible.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by ImSkeptical on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:18AM (#16187328)
The scenario I'm describing doesn't involve any sort of violence or torture, which again, makes me think you're missing my point or conflating my position with something else.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by maxxxxx on Friday January 19, 2018 @12:35PM (#16188042)
You mentioned a scenario where police beats a thief. How is that not violence? What's your position? I am really curious.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by ImSkeptical on Friday January 19, 2018 @02:06PM (#16188793)
If you are curious, I suggest you read my comments in this chain.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by maxxxxx on Friday January 19, 2018 @03:28PM (#16189481)
I did and I think you are advocating violence or torture in certain cases.
Re:CIA rendition flights from rustic North Carolina called t... by ImSkeptical on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:44PM (#16191757)
In my original example the dilemma was between denying a suspected terrorist the right to consult with a lawyer and risking a nuclear terrorist attack. I gave this as an example of when idealism and pragmatism are in conflict. When you objected that this was unrealistic, I responded by giving a real life example where idealism and pragmatism were in conflict.

The purpose of my example was to create a situation where it should be obvious the right move is to go against idealism. The reason is, if your starting point is something like "We must never deny people their rights" I'd like to show you an extreme example where, actually, we must. If you can agree on the extreme example, then the discussion becomes a matter of degree - i.e. when is it okay to deny people their rights versus when it is not. This is actually the more nuanced and realistic discussion that has applicability to the real world.