News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Walkable Streets Are More Economically Productive by rayiner on Thursday January 18, 2018 @01:00PM (#16179515)
Economics is to urban planning like structural mechanics is to architecture. It's a way of describing a justification ("we need a beam to hold up the floor, and the math shows why") not a justification in and of itself. It's also a way of bridging differences in subjective preferences "whether we have a post or a cantilever, we need to hold up this awning, and the math shows why").

Most Americans don't live in cities. To a degree that stands in stark contrast to Europe. Over 60% of the population of Germany's capital lives in the city proper. Just 11% of the population of America's capital lives in the city proper. To Americans, quite reasonably, pedestrians are just in the way of the offices and businesses they need to drive to. Economics helps explain in concrete terms why they might prefer to support policies that on their face seem to be against their interest.

Re:Walkable Streets Are More Economically Productive by pcwalton on Thursday January 18, 2018 @03:00PM (#16180774)
> To a degree that stands in stark contrast to Europe. Over 60% of the population of Germany's capital lives in the city proper. Just 11% of the population of America's capital lives in the city proper.

Eh, D.C. is an outlier due to its special legal/territorial status. And the numbers are uneven in Europe as well. In Los Angeles, 3,976,322/13,131,431 (30.3%) of the population of the metro area lives in L.A. proper. Compare to Paris, where only 2,206,488/12,405,426 (17.8%) of the population of the metro area lives in Paris proper.

Re:Walkable Streets Are More Economically Productive by rayiner on Thursday January 18, 2018 @03:53PM (#16181334)
Out of the 10 largest U.S. cities, only San Antonio has a majority of the population of its metro area. Most aren't even close, at 20-30%. Out of the 10 largest EU cities, only three have less than half the population in the core city: Madrid, Paris, and Hamburg. And Madrid is close to the line--48%.
Re:Walkable Streets Are More Economically Productive by dionidium on Monday January 22, 2018 @03:17PM (#16207524)
You can't use political borders in this way. You're trying to make an argument about population differences between cities and their suburbs, but every city defines these borders differently (to sometimes include almost all of their "suburbs", sometimes none, and everything else in between).

The key to recognizing how absurd this is: your argument would have to drastically change if each city moved its political borders +/- 15 miles in either direction, but nothing on the ground would actually be any different (that is, there wouldn't suddenly be more people living in one kind of environment and fewer in the other, although, definitionally, that would appear to be the case).

These lines are politically drawn. They don't support arguments of the kind you're making.

Why does San Antonio have a much larger share of its metro's population than does San Francisco? Because the borders of San Antonio extend to cover ~465 square miles to San Francisco's ~44. What does that tell us about these two cities? Basically nothing. (In fact, this information directly misleads us into thinking all sorts of things that aren't true (for example, that San Antonio might be bigger than San Francisco).

Re:Walkable Streets Are More Economically Productive by littlestymaar on Friday January 19, 2018 @06:53AM (#16185540)
Paris is also an outlier, and the administrative distinction between Paris and the «petite couronne» is kind of artificial. In an urbanistic point of view, there is not much difference between inside and outside the «périphérique ».
Re:Walkable Streets Are More Economically Productive by tptacek on Thursday January 18, 2018 @01:36PM (#16179922)
When you say "don't live in cities", you mean "live outside of city centers", right? Because the overwhelming majority of Americans live in major metro areas.
Re:Walkable Streets Are More Economically Productive by rayiner on Thursday January 18, 2018 @02:19PM (#16180378)
Not just outside the city center, but outside the legal limits of the cities at the center of those metro areas.