Re:Ask HN: What is the Bitcoin price level at which miners w...
by solarkraft on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @04:49PM
(#16172291)
The question wasn't specific about the number of miners stopping operations.
At 0 miners indeed transactions will halt and only resume when somebody starts mining again.
As the number of miners reaches zero it will become trivial to perform a >50% attack. It will be much simpler to replace the 'legitimate' block chain with an own one as nobody will be there to check it.
I up voted your answer.
Re:Ask HN: What is the Bitcoin price level at which miners w...
by ecesena on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @04:58PM
(#16172396)
Thanks, I see now, OP's asking about mines, not necessarily miners (though I guess it's a bit hard to distinguish... if I mine, do I have a mine? how many cores should I have to qualify that as a mine?)
Anyway, on the >50% attack, I'm not totally in agreement. The attack can drop transactions, but can't forge any (which, btw, goes towards the "there won't be transactions"). If the network would ever restart, it will be eventually verified.
I'm sure my answer is technically correct. Transactions only happen if a block is mined. If all miners suddenly stop mining, there are no blocks mined, there are no transactions, all bitcoins are frozen.
I understand this seems an absurd situation, but this was the question, or have I misunderstood it?