Re:Ask HN: Should I choose Sun Solaris or Linux?
by gaius on Thursday August 19, 2010 @08:19AM
(#1617129)
Well, no, not really. Just one example, Sun developed DTrace, a bit later Red Hat got SystemTap. Who's leading and who's following there? Sun has ZFS and Oracle has BTRFS and SGI released XFS, all of which are well in advance of ext3. So while it is fashionable to bash Unix for being old-fashioned and praise Linux for being "advanced", the reality is a lot more subtle than that.
Re:Ask HN: Should I choose Sun Solaris or Linux?
by davidw on Thursday August 19, 2010 @08:25AM
(#1617143)
I never said Linux was more advanced. What it is, is "good enough" and improving all the time: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Disruptivetechnology.gif
Especially since it's easier to find people to work with it, more open, and not driven by a billionaire who wants you over a barrel.
Also, I think that Oracle is quickly putting paid to the sort of environment where innovations like dtrace happen, although I could be wrong.
I don't see it "running into the ground" - people will be using it for many years in the future. However, the supply of people picking it for new projects probably just dried up quite a bit. People will 'grow up' knowing how to work with Linux, because that's what they tried at home, at school, what they learned on the job, and what their friends know. Those network effects mean that it'll mostly be sensible to keep switching to Linux over time, gradually, unless Solaris suddenly sprouts something that makes it a must-have, which I don't see.