News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by geezerjay on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:08AM (#16165838)
> Someone who consistently practices a craft for 8 hours a day will accumulate >10,000 hours in just 4 years, sufficient to become an expert in most non-professional activites.

That assumes that all those hours result in skill impfovemeonts. They do not. Commuters don't become expert drivers just because they get stuck in traffic for hours a day.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by laumars on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:22AM (#16165885)
You say that, but my clutch control jumped leaps and bounds (back when I drove a manual for commuting), to the point that I could keep distance with the car in front while half a sleep and without needing to tap the break peddle.

Some of the other skills I learned were less admirable. Eg learning to use a touch screen phone while keeping an eye on the car in front (I'd only do this if traffic was stationary though). And learning how to accelerate quickly because I needed to steal a small gap at a busy junction.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by jwdunne on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:39AM (#16165954)
Yes. A good demo of this is starting off in 3rd gear (for demo purposes!). Without training fine clutch control, you'll just stall. After hours of traffic, it's easy.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by baddox on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:36AM (#16165948)
Indeed, I would imagine that thousands of hours of commuting would make one an expert at those specific skills. That said, I imagine the skill ceiling is quite low and likely reached long before 10,000 hours, and the skill set is certainly different from what most people mean by “expert driver.”
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by taxicabjesus on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @03:32AM (#16166387)
> That said, I imagine the skill ceiling is quite low and likely reached long before 10,000 hours, and the skill set is certainly different from what most people mean by “expert driver.”

It doesnt take much practice to become a marginally-skilled driver. But that doesn't mean there's little difference between marginal drivers and people who spend their entire day behind the steering wheel...

I once guesstimated that I spent maybe 7,500 hours (over 3.5 years) driving around in taxis. Towards the end of that period I started to notice things that the other cars on the road would likely do, and point this out to my passengers. "See that car? it's going to change lanes and that other guy is going to have to slam on his brakes..."

After I 'retired', I was driving with my mother. Our light turned green, but I saw that the car in the cross traffic couldn't see that his light had turned red (on account of the sunset). I waited, and watched as he slammed on his brakes.

There's something to putting in time on any activity. I think the relevant saying is not "practice makes perfect", but "perfect practice makes perfect". If you spend 10,000 hours practicing something wrong it won't be as helpful as 1,000 hours practicing it right.

Bruce Lee said, "I fear not the man who has practiced 10,000 kicks once, but I fear the man who has practiced one kick 10,000 times."

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by kaybe on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @07:39AM (#16167392)
I really wonder how all this unspoken communication is going to change with self-driving cars.

On the German Autobahn, the amount of observing and consideration is very high, and if people are new it can be very stressful. You basically have to keep in mind everyone around you, their respective speeds, potential moves and how a move from you will change their options and responses.

One common situation is when you come up behind a slow car on your lane, but the lane to the left (where you need to go to keep your current speed and overtake) has somebody coming up fast from the back. If you move there, you might force that person to brake. Now, they obviously see your situation and might slow down a little or speed up, so you can adjust your speed (speed up and pull into the left lane or lay off the gas and delay switching just long enough to let them pass). If there is another left lane they might move over to that too if possible. In this case, the communication is mostly in those small changes in speed that tell you their intention.

Now how should I read an automatic car? It's going to be very chaotic before we figure it out.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by ghostbrainalpha on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @02:59PM (#16171227)
I worry about the transition as well.

Hopefully it won't be as bad as you are thinking if all the car AI's make the same choices in every situation. That way you can get a much better feel for how those cars operate.

In reality I think your concern, shared by others will result in cars that act a lot more like buses. Almost always in the slow lane. Going a very safe speed. Leaving the faster/passing lanes to more dangerous humans.

The autonomous cars may soon be required to have visible markings so that they are easy to tell apart as well. Perhaps the color yellow could be reserved for them?

These changes will still be an adjustment, but hopefully one that doesn't result in a major number of accidents.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by olivermarks on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @12:13PM (#16169658)
I worry that driving is the last continuous attention/frequently applied skill thing humans do, and that they will quickly deskill when they assume that a machine will automatically take them where they want to go.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by robotresearcher on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @10:22AM (#16168609)
One option is that the cars explicitly communicate, and make a joint plan that minimizes acceleration, danger and unexpectedness.

Of course a legacy non-robot car is a special case the robots have to think about carefully. The robots will give you similar signals to those given by human drivers now. These have been active areas of research for a while now.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @08:59AM (#16167889)
People can't operate perfectly. "Good practice makes better" is my version, not half as pithy.

"Practice makes perfect" is a bit weird as a motivational phrase, as no one who has practised ever got perfect. In your version, who can practice perfectly?

Bruce Lee was on point though I think.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @10:49AM (#16168837)
"Practice makes permanent" is another version, warning against poor form when practicing as those bad habits will stick.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by robbiep on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @07:14AM (#16167275)
That’s a great anecdote. I’d also suggest that there are a bunch of people who could spend exactly the same period behind the wheel as you and not develop those skills though. Some people plateau and something about their makeup stops them from developing those higher ‘intuitive’ skills
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by goldenkey on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:21AM (#16165876)
That's a false equivalence if there ever was one. When you get stuck in traffic, you aren't choosing conditions of adversity which will guide you towards higher difficulty. One could easily make the comparison between traffic jams and monotony. When one practices a skill, they get to choose the level of difficulty as well as a number of other factors related to the activity. A traffic jam is hardly comparable and it's not surprising that monotony does not really improve anyones' driving skills. However, compare your driving skills to someone from India where there are no traffic lights, and you'll probably go running out of the car. They are able to take higher risks because they deal with it every day.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by geezerjay on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:27AM (#16165909)
> When you get stuck in traffic, you aren't choosing conditions of adversity which will guide you towards higher difficulty.

Neither do you or anyone in general when working a 9-to-5 job.

Hours spent on a job do not represent skill increases. They only represent how much of your life you spent on something.

I'll also add that "5 years of experience vs 1 year of experience 5 times" is a known thing.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by yesenadam on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @02:36AM (#16166161)
Traffic jams, 9-to-5 job.. I'm not sure what those have to do with the topic at all. Yes, the 10,000 hours thing doesn't include every possible human (in)activity, no-one thinks it does.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by fellellor on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @03:05AM (#16166274)
Actually we do have traffic lights. They are just optional.

Jokes aside, the conditions are different. Most traffic in India is extremely slow moving, which makes those risks possible. Go to a country where the to Urban driving speed is over 50 kph (~30 mph), say 80-100 kph, Indian drivers will refuse to take those risks.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @03:46PM (#16171632)
>Most traffic in India is extremely slow moving, which makes those risks possible. Go to a country where the to Urban driving speed is over 50 kph (~30 mph), say 80-100 kph, Indian drivers will refuse to take those risks.

That explains a lot.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by mtgx on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @08:56AM (#16167864)
I think the 10,000h thing should have a caveat that you also must do the 10,000 with the purpose of improving that skill, and not just doing something for 10,000 hours absent-minded.

So if you wanted to improve your driving then you'd do 10,000h of driving in which you'd try to become better than the last hour in every one of those hours.

Similarly, runners don't just do "running for fun" when they try to improve their skill, or count walking as part of their 10,000 hours. They try to beat their previous scores when they train.

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by epicide on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @09:37AM (#16168172)
This is exactly what Cal Newport talks about in So Good They Can't Ignore You. He calls it "deliberate practice" and gives the examples of playing guitar.

He (Cal) started playing around the same time as [professional guitarist] and claims to have likely played around the same number of hours. The difference was that he stuck to songs he was comfortable with. If he ever tried to learn a song that was out of his reach, he would give up and learn a different song. Contrast with the other guy, who would constantly push himself to not only play songs just outside of his comfort zone, but push himself to play them faster.

I believe he used a phrase that really stuck with me: the idea of "being comfortable with being uncomfortable".

Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by JabavuAdams on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @10:08AM (#16168467)
Not a good comparison. We're discussing active practice. It turns out that if you draw for 20 hours a week, you will get better at drawing. If you read art-history books for 10 hours a week during your commute, you'll get better at art history. If you cycle-commute to work for 5 hours a week, you'll get fit.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by cocktailpeanuts on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @02:38AM (#16166172)
There's a difference between going through the motion and actually doing something that improves your skill. Commuting doesn't help with improving your "driving skill" (whatever that means) just like eating 3 meals every day doesn't make you a master champion eater that wins the hot dog eating contest.
Re:Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities em... by Swizec on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @03:22AM (#16166342)
You say that but after 30 years on this earth I almost never choke on my food anymore.