People's lives may be ruined by this - they've often essentially been scammed into investing in cryptocurrency because they cannot understand the risks. If a financial adviser were promoting bitcoin to most people, it'd be illegal. I don't think it's fair to say this is OK because it won't affect people you know.
Proportional to the total market is important because it puts into perspective how few people will really be impacted, and if it is something that could spread into the economy as a whole.
Found the stats: https://coinspectator.com/news/127996/survey-finds-average-b...
No, they shouldn't have. But many people don't actually understand what a high-risk market is, and especially not one as volatile as Bitcoin. They've heard their cousin/friend/waiter made a couple thousand bucks off it, done some googling, and found several thousand people saying this is the next big thing, with fancy graphs and miracle use cases and so on and so forth to prove it. Big well-known news sources like Bloomberg talking about it, and how big well-known investment banks are interested in it. This is the end result of what lack of regulation looks like.
People get bamboozled - similar to many scams, you might get tricked into losing a couple of hundred bucks and calling it a life lesson, or you might get scammed into losing your life savings and winding up in severe debt.
A few people (and it's more than a few) being impacted enough to cause them to be extremely worried about how they'll pay their bills, how they'll afford to keep a roof over their head in their later years, is important. It's maybe not as important to you as widespread economic collapse, but it's nothing to pretend isn't an issue. The comment you were originally replying to wasn't talking about economic collapse - it was talking about the impact on individual people.
Is that an appeal to consequences or did you have a different point?
That being said, scammers, shysters and pumpers always say bombastic shit like you are saying. That is how they get all the rubes to buy into their scam.
Beyond the scammers there is a lot of hard computer science research happenning.
You don’t have to tell me exact figures for how many people you personally know in each category, but my point is that if both figures are sufficiently small in absolute terms then the example is meaningless.
So you think a 1000% increase in likelihood to win the lottery is meaningful?
I’m not saying a 1000% increase is insignificant relatively speaking. I’m saying that in the absolute context, it can be essentially meaningless. Which circles back to my point: you should add an absolute context to your numbers instead of just saying you know more cryptocurrency millionaires than startup millionaires.
> you should add an absolute context to your numbers instead of just saying you know more cryptocurrency millionaires than startup millionaires.
My intention is not writing a paper here in HN but showing an observation that impacts the life of people around me because like it or not they can spend the rest of their life doing whatever they want at an scale I have not seen in my lifetime in an underdeveloped country like Argentina.
Beyond all your calculations it is something singular to note and that is why I mentioned it here.
What this means is that for most people when crypto crashes, it sucks but will simply be a cool story. This isn't .com or the housing bubble where many people's lives were ruined.
Of course with the craze, the stats could have changed over the last few months.