News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by 0wing on Monday January 15, 2018 @09:23PM (#16155289)
Bitcoin and blockchain systems are nearly all designed to exploit new users and extract capital from greater fools who are too late to the game and didn't read or understand the rules and fine print.

Satoshi's Bitcoin and many of the crypto-currencies that have followed create and distribute the supply that effectively creates a decentralized pyramid-ponzi scheme. Semantically, a more accurate term is needed;

Bitcoin is a Satoshi scheme,

.. or a "Nakamoto Scheme" https://prestonbyrne.com/2017/12/08/bitcoin_ponzi/

Imagine an economic policy that uses a "limited" amount of pie as "currency". Bitcoin gave half of this pie away to the first few users who arrived in exchange for the least amount of work/effort possible. Any user arriving later will need to waste more hashing power (computational work) in exchange for a smaller sum of newly generation coins for a successfully mined block reward. or the user might be convinced to purchase a previously produced coin from one of the early adopters. Buying a Bitcoin is worse than zero-sum, as money from buyers is exchanged for previously generated coins, the network must increasingly waste computations and energy.

Satoshi's economic model creates a system where participation is only beneficial if you can exploit the ignorance of another new user who enters the network after you. Bitcoin effectively relies on psychological manipulation though deceptive marketing claims like

  "Bitcoin is deflationary"
  "Bitcoin is rare"
  "Bitcoin is a store of value"
When what actually happens is you either need to enrich someone who generated the coin for far less than you're paying, or waste more electricity and computational work than other early users for significantly less share of the pie.

If you understand the computer science behind Bitcoin, you'll realize how ridiculous the false equivalency to gold is.

1. The claim of "rare" doesn't exactly hold true.

Consider the 10,000 BTC pizza - how did this happen? This was the direct result of Satoshi's economic policy, granting vast sums of BTC to mint out very quickly very early for a short duration to the very small pool of people who ran the software. Satoshi's algorithm produced BTC in plentiful quantities enabling the 10,000BTC pizza - thus it wasn't rare if you were Satoshi and the dozen other early whales hording as much as possible, until the algorithm begins cutting off the production and limiting later users from producing coins, starving the economy. Now there's a psychological game being played, where public relations and marketing must convince new users to buy in. Because the exchanges are unregulated, they can manipulate the spot price though wash trading and painting the tape [2] (where trades are falsified and you just sell the same item back and forth to your friend for a higher and higher price).

The supply was created by running a piece of software. It's not magic. Most of the supply was produced very early on and as much as 30% of all Bitcoins are owned by less than 100 people.

  Best estimates are that there are about one million 
  holders of Bitcoin;  47 individuals hold about 30 percent, 
  another 900 hold a further 20 percent, the next 10,000 
  about 25% and another million about 20%, with 5% being 
  lost.  So 1/10th of one percent represent about half the 
  holdings of Bitcoin and 1 percent close to 80 percent 
  (http://www.businessinsider.com/927-people-own-half-
  of-the-bitcoins-2013-12). The concentration of Litecoin 
  ownership is similar 
  (http://litecoin-rich-list.blogspot.com).  
  Most of the big wallets have been in place from early on, 
  so sitting back and watching your capital grow has been a 
  very successful strategy.


  The distribution of Bitcoin holdings  looks much like the 
  distribution of wealth in North Korea and makes the 
  China’s and even the US’ wealth distribution look like 
  that of a workers’ paradise
2. Easy migration to more advanced e-cash services See: https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/views/all/

3. Bitcoin network requires ASIC miners, largely centralized in China [3]. Assuming the inveitable surpassing of a more advanced cryptosytem making Bitcoin obsolete, as the market is informed there will be a decline in BTC's spot price and once this falls below the cost of OPEX for miners, the hardware goes offline and the network will cease to function. Maximalists will attempt to offer an emergency fork, in any attempt to save their "investment", just as they have developed the lightening network to create centeralized payment hubs, so "investors" can act as liquidity providors and take fees, instead of miners.

4. Electricty usage is unsustainable, GOTO 3

5. [4]

  Bitcoin value is make-believe just like money. But even 
  though there is bitcoin-sphere governance, there are no 
  bitcoin-sphere assets. Taxes are not paid in bitcoin. 
  There is no FDIC, only hackers that lift a million here 
  and there. And when nation-states decide its a nuisance, 
  what are the guns of bitcoin? It’s anonymity? From the 
  same government that created PRISM and then used 
  mind-magic* to make everyone forget about PRISM? Please. 
  You may think crypto-currencies that require more power 
  than a small country to run can fly under the radar, but 
  somehow I think not indefinitely. After all, becoming the 
  next big thing would mean its a threat to the American 
  dollar, do you really think the US Gov will shrug and say 
  “shucks bitcoin went from a ponzi-novelty to something 
  that will totally usurp this hegemony we worked so hard to 
  make. Guess we’ll have to call it a day.” (If you think 
  this, sell your Bitcoin and buy an imagination.)

  The day you can pay tax bills to a government in Bitcoin 
  is probably the day you can rest easy. Until then dear 
  Bitcoin holders, you do have something of value, just like 
  the Louisiana territory has value. But in this 1800’s 
  metaphor, what makes you so sure you’re America?

  Monopoly money is good to have, while the game is still 
  running. 
[1] https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/86/is-it-possibl...

http://www.businessinsider.com/bitcoin-inequality-2014-1

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6r04gfWfRkE

[3] https://qz.com/1055126/photos-china-has-one-of-worlds-larges...

[4] https://hackernoon.com/the-guns-of-bitcoin-1f779309a718

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by beaner on Monday January 15, 2018 @09:50PM (#16155411)
You seem to be confused. Bitcoin doesn't require buy-in. It doesn't give any promise of a positive return.

Simultaneously, you argue that "easy migration to more advanced e-currencies" is a deficiency, even though they use the same scarcity model.

The rest of your post is just ranty conjecture.

If you want one thought on why digital currency has value, consider this:

Currently, to send money between two people in the US, it takes 3 business days, typically costs some transaction fee, and is limited to the range of the border. It is slow, expensive, and local.

But we are in the age of information. We used to have the same restrictions for paper letters. But now I can send an email to anyone in the world in seconds for no effort. It is fast, cheap, and global.

Why shouldn't money be the same way? There is no incentive for traditional finance to improve its product, because regulation is so high that it is difficult for new entrants. Complexity and incompatibility is an advantage; it creates lock-in. There is no incentive for governments to improve, because full control of their local systems is exactly what they want.

Fast, cheap, global money is in the interest of the people, but not the incumbents. Decentralized scarcity is what enables it.

Now that it is here, why would we have 200 non-interoperable, complicated, slow local systems, when we could have one that works everywhere, according to a predictable economic model? Or a variety of economic models, that the world could choose from and watch play out against each other, not based on jurisdiction, but practicality?

Like other types of information, money will flow through the path of least resistance. As crypto becomes more accessible, all of the world's money will flow into it, because it will be better.

Parts of the world which have never had access to traditional financial services will leapfrog it and go straight to crypto, connecting directly to the rest of the world and taking advantage of the ability for people to be their own bank, instead of waiting for permission to connect to the old system.

Anything that is just information can be made digital, and anything that is digital trends towards fast, cheap, and free. Money is an example of something that is just information, like music, movies, and news.

All money will flow to digital currency in time because it is money that is built for the information age. We are at the very start of the S-curve.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 15, 2018 @09:55PM (#16155436)
> Currently, to send money between two people in the US, it takes 3 business days, typically costs some transaction fee, and is limited to the range of the border. It is slow, expensive, and local.

I received funds via Fedwire today. It took about five minutes. Both sides’ banks waived fees on account of our account balances.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by beaner on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:02PM (#16155460)
It's true that some banking systems are improving in terms of speed. I don't think it's a coincidence that it's happening now that crypto has been around for 8 years, and is increasing in size.

Most immediate US-based sends and receives are virtual, based on 2nd-layer systems like Venmo and PayPal, not actually moving money but updating the numbers in your account before funds land.

Unfortunately for the Fed, speed and fees are not the whole story. There are still the problems of it not being global, not being private, inflating away, and not actually being owned by the people. (See the Cyprus banking haircut.)

These are small factors in most people's daily lives, but are important enough at a large scale to have money flow in the direction of crypto, and as a result all money will flow towards it until everyone has these advantages.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by grey-area on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:17PM (#16155525)
Since FPS (2009) in the UK Payments take seconds, not days. I'm not sure what you mean by virtual payments - all payments are entries in a ledger nowadays, they don't move physical money around.

Re the Cyprus banking haircut I wouldn't be so sure you are protected from this kind of action - exchanges, developers and miners all have leverage and have already used it to fork entire currencies, and force changes on users, impose currency controls, impose local laws (KYC etc) if you want to spend and exchange the currency.

I think on balance I prefer a slightly inflationary currency with low fees, few middlemen, and trusted counterparties and agencies to hold money (i.e. banks). Happy to ditch government control and our current system of money management though for deterministic inflation.

I also prefer one which is not at the mercy of developers or miners, and does not attempt distributed anonymity, which places severe constraints on speed, energy usage and consistency, and did not have high fees. At present Bitcoin is completely unsuited to global trade and unlikely to improve soon. I think if you were a little more clear-eyed about the downsides of current cryptocurrencies, you'd make a would be more convincing case.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:19PM (#16155529)
> I don't think it's a coincidence that it's happening now that crypto has been around for 8 years, and is increasing in size

Fedwire is run directly by the Federal Reserve [1]. It traces its history to the first electronic funds transfers, which started in 1915. It started doing automated transfers in the early 1980s. Until the 1980s, it was free; after that it costs between 3 and 80¢ for member banks. Almost every American bank will waive their mark-up (or even the whole fee) for accounts with over $15 to 50 thousand.

Internationaly, there are numerous RTGS systems including but not limited to SWIFT, CLS, et cetera.

> See the Cyprus banking haircut

See the MtGox haircut.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fedwire

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by beaner on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:21PM (#16155539)
Maybe you can elaborate on the reasons why fedwire is not more popular than, say, ACH? I suspect there is a reason that stems from its centralization.
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:59PM (#16155708)
> why fedwire is not more popular than, say, ACH?

To understand this, we have to compare two classes of systems: real-time gross settlement (RTGS) [1] and net settlement [2].

Suppose you and I are banks. At 9AM I send you ten dollars, at 10AM you send me ten dollars, at 3PM you send me another ten dollars and finally, at 4PM, I send you ten dollars. At the end of the day, we're back where we started (minus transaction costs). If we actually moved the cash between our banks, that would be RTGS. It's as fast as funds can travel. It results in a lot of paperwork and means we must have the cash for potential transfers immediately available. No exceptions.

We grab a beer and say "let's settle, on the net, at the end of the day." The same transfer instructions come in. This time, though, no cash moves intraday. At the end of the day, we tally everything up and find we're balanced. We move money around internally an call it a day. Much easier, and therefore, cheaper. Moreover, between when I deducted the funds at 9AM and may have had to settle at 4PM, I might have made a margin loan. This is net settlement.

The next day, at net settlement, I owe you ten more dollars than I have. We grab a beer and say "let's settle the day after. That way, we can sell or borrow if we come up short." This is net settlement with delayed settlement.

From top to bottom, the system gets slower and more profitable. Many of these costs, e.g. intraday liquidity and risk management, don't go away with cryptocurrencies. Net settlement will always be cheaper than real-time settlement, and delayed settlement cheaper still.

Payers prefer ACH because it gives them time to scramble, if needed. Receivers prefer to receive by wire because it produces immediately-available funds. What gets chosen depends on negotiating leverage. I struggle to see the advantage of a crypto-currency based RTGS, which is less reversible than EFTs, slower than wires, and more expensive than both for most participants.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real-time_gross_settlement

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_settlement

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by paulmd on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @02:01AM (#16156342)
> Most immediate US-based sends and receives are virtual, based on 2nd-layer systems like Venmo and PayPal, not actually moving money but updating the numbers in your account before funds land.

This is really only the case in the US. Most of the rest of the world can have bank transfers that are cleared in seconds, for free. The US is just way behind on this, it's a solved problem for Europeans.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by beaner on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @02:51AM (#16156506)
Actually, most of the rest of the world does not have any access to traditional finance at all.
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by redorb on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:53PM (#16155681)
Why not paypal accounts with paypal debit cards? .. paypal can credit instantly and the card pulls to cash.

How about western union?

I don't think crypto coins or their blockchains solve billion dollar problems. I'd guess VC's have bet almost a trillion and the public a few trillion ~ this means a lot of trouble for investors and also perhaps it could wind down slowly and last for 10-15 years...

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:00PM (#16155714)
> Why not paypal accounts with paypal debit cards?

That's a fair solution. I trust my bank more than PayPal, but that's a matter of preference. Both systems are cheap, real time and covered with decades of institutional protection.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by redorb on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:20PM (#16164270)
IMHO, Paypal as a buyer is insanely good protection. Of course on the seller side it's rough - with horror stories included.
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by furyg3 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:07AM (#16157845)
I just sent €3 to a friend at another bank (we're both in the Netherlands). It was there within the hour. It was also free.

If I send €3 worth of bitcoin it would have taken anywhere from 1-6 hours and would have cost me around €20 to process the transaction.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by nkassis on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:10PM (#16155494)
There a difference between saying digital currencies will take over vs bitcoin being the currency that takes over or others with similar flaw. As the first line of OP's post points out he's not saying every single digital currency scheme will turn out to be ponzi schemes but I think he makes some very valid points about many of them.

I don't think the early digital currencies we have are going to be the right ones to fulfill the type of future you are envisioning.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by beaner on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:19PM (#16155533)
His first sentence is factually incorrect.
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by atarian on Monday January 15, 2018 @09:50PM (#16155413)
I think a more likely explanation is that Bitcoin started off as a well-intentioned project that out-scaled the original creator(s)' expectations. I personally think it's one of the most innovative pieces of software written in this era.
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by pat_space on Monday January 15, 2018 @09:34PM (#16155344)
This was eye-opening. Thanks for posting. I will share this with my friends.
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by whataretensors on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @01:04AM (#16156167)
1. Early bitcoin users shoulder more risk than later users. They are rewarded for pushing the blockchain forward. You could argue disproportionately, but the rules are set in stone from the beginning.

3. There are other coins that do not require asics or have as high of energy cost.

5. What exactly is a government going to do? They could perhaps take control of the chain? The cost would be enormous. They could attempt to crack quantum, but some quantum-resistant variants are coming out.

An alternative view is that this is just the free market expressing itself through cryptocurrency - at a higher resolution than we've seen before.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by thebokehwokeh2 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:27AM (#16157969)
> An alternative view is that this is just the free market expressing itself through cryptocurrency

If anything, the bitcoin experiment has shown how easy it is for entities with disproportionate amounts of wealth to completely overwhelm and game a free market.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by 0wing on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @03:24PM (#16162081)
1. The Bitcoin algorithm gave early Bitcoin miners much more of the supply for measurably less work/capital costs. Satoshi designed the supply to go almost entirely to early adopters. Just as easy the algorithm could have been designed to match work input with reward output, but instead all later users must work harder to earn less.

5. Ban exchanges, make sales/purchase illegal like how localbitcoin dealers being arrested for money transmission violations.

Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by sgspace on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:33PM (#16155851)
Wow thats a lot of words to say "I didn't buy Bitcoin when it was cheap".
Re:Goldman Sachs Report Explores Use of Bitcoin as Currency by 0wing on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @12:04AM (#16155971)
There's no reason for new users to become bag holders.

Sellers and "HODLers" rely on psychological manipulation and ignorance of new users to sell bitcoins produced by the software for low effort.