I think you unilaterally decided that these situations are rare. I wholeheartedly disagree with that sentiment. This is why we are having this debate.
> A dropout's work is just as good, yes, in all but a few corner cases.
You'd have to be seriously screwed up in the head to actually believe that as a fact. What possible line of reasoning can you be using to say that someone who is formally trained and educated in a discipline is worst or equal to someone who is not? Are you saying that formal education is a total waste of time?
Yes there are exceptions and there have been prodigious people who were ahead of their time but that is why we have a word to describe these extremely rare occurrences.
> In fact, they usually dropped out because some business was willing to pay them for their work now, rather than wait till they graduated.
Do you have a source for this information?
I my experience from software development, self-thought developers tend to be more competent because they have learnt design principles through actual experience, and therefore have a deeper understanding of the rationale. School educated developers more often have learned design principles as dogma, and don't understand the context and limitations of the principles.
You're not allowed to get personal here. Once you cool off, maybe we can resume this.
These situations are comparatively rare. If you have to reach for them, it may as well be conceding the point: A dropout's work is just as good, yes, in all but a few corner cases.
In fact, they usually dropped out because some business was willing to pay them for their work now, rather than wait till they graduated.