News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Simone Giertz makes a living creating shitty robots (2016... by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:39AM (#16149536)
Every time this argument comes up, the first reaction is to talk about fields where lives are on the line: Would you trust a doctor without a degree? Etc.

These situations are comparatively rare. If you have to reach for them, it may as well be conceding the point: A dropout's work is just as good, yes, in all but a few corner cases.

In fact, they usually dropped out because some business was willing to pay them for their work now, rather than wait till they graduated.

Re:Simone Giertz makes a living creating shitty robots (2016... by computerex on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:58AM (#16149607)
> These situations are comparatively rare. If you have to reach for them, it may as well be conceding the point: A dropout's work is just as good, yes, in all but a few corner cases.

I think you unilaterally decided that these situations are rare. I wholeheartedly disagree with that sentiment. This is why we are having this debate.

> A dropout's work is just as good, yes, in all but a few corner cases.

You'd have to be seriously screwed up in the head to actually believe that as a fact. What possible line of reasoning can you be using to say that someone who is formally trained and educated in a discipline is worst or equal to someone who is not? Are you saying that formal education is a total waste of time?

Yes there are exceptions and there have been prodigious people who were ahead of their time but that is why we have a word to describe these extremely rare occurrences.

> In fact, they usually dropped out because some business was willing to pay them for their work now, rather than wait till they graduated.

Do you have a source for this information?

Re:Simone Giertz makes a living creating shitty robots (2016... by olavk on Monday January 15, 2018 @07:23AM (#16150059)
> What possible line of reasoning can you be using to say that someone who is formally trained and educated in a discipline is worst or equal to someone who is not? Are you saying that formal education is a total waste of time?

I my experience from software development, self-thought developers tend to be more competent because they have learnt design principles through actual experience, and therefore have a deeper understanding of the rationale. School educated developers more often have learned design principles as dogma, and don't understand the context and limitations of the principles.

Re:Simone Giertz makes a living creating shitty robots (2016... by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:07AM (#16149641)
You'd have to be seriously screwed up in the head to actually believe that as a fact.

You're not allowed to get personal here. Once you cool off, maybe we can resume this.