News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by revorad on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @11:43AM (#1614474)
What consumer OS on affordable computers (that leaves Macs out) was/is better than Windows?

It took the court system to slow them down.

That was not for their dominant desktop OS, it was for using their monopoly to push IE and server products.

You can call out Microsoft on dodgy anti-competitive behaviour in some respects, but you cannot take away credit for building the solid product that is Windows. Heck, even now after goofing up with Vista, they are back with Windows 7.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by daleharvey on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @12:07PM (#1614563)
I much much much prefer desktop linux, I would hesitate to call windows decent, let alone by far the best.

Yet I have still found it as much as impossible to buy a computer without windows preinstalled.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by revorad on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @12:24PM (#1614628)
I prefer and use linux too, but the typical HN user doesn't represent the consumer market.
Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by gnaritas on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @02:13PM (#1615026)
> I much much much prefer desktop linux

So do I, but that Linux didn't exist when Windows became dominant; it came much later.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by hasenj on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @08:49PM (#1616117)
and even now, it lacks the beauty of OS X, which is rather unfortunate.

I use Xubuntu, and it's the best damn work station I've ever used, but sometimes I wish gtk apps were a bit more beautiful.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by damoncali on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @02:26PM (#1615080)
Windows won because DOS was already everywhere. It wasn't the best product. I would argue OS/2 and Macintosh were pretty significantly better. It's not a coincidence that it took this long (Windows 7) for MS to produce a decent operating system - they are now having to compete on quality. But you don't even have to buy the argument that Windows was sub-par. It doesn't matter, because that's not why MS won.

Just as MS used the omnipresent Windows platform to push Office, IE, and countless other products (with varying success) they used DOS to push Windows. That is why Windows won.

There's nothing dodgy about it - the point is there is more than one way to win the market, and being the best product is pretty far down on the list.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by revorad on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @04:44PM (#1615528)
Of course, Microsoft used DOS to push Windows and perhaps OS/2 was better in some ways, but the Wikipedia article suggests OS/2 lost because Windows was better in some important ways.

The collaboration between IBM and Microsoft unraveled in 1990, between the releases of Windows 3.0 and OS/2 1.3. Initially, at least publicly, Microsoft continued to insist the future belonged to OS/2. Steve Ballmer of Microsoft even took to calling OS/2 "Windows Plus".[9] However, during this time, Windows 3.0 became a tremendous success, selling millions of copies in its first year.[10] Much of its success was because Windows 3.0 (along with MS-DOS) was bundled with most new computers.[11] OS/2, on the other hand, was only available as an expensive stand-alone software package. In addition, OS/2 lacked device drivers for many common devices such as printers, particularly non-IBM hardware.[12] Windows, on the other hand, supported a much larger variety of hardware.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OS/2

The other question to consider is why another PC OS didn't come up to compete with DOS/Windows considering that Microsoft actually helped open up the hardware ecosystem. A dominant player with most of the "market share" need not stop a new better player (see web search). Maybe it's worth acknowledging that making a good OS is a hard problem which MS cracked better than the rest.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by slug on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @10:21PM (#1616316)
There were other PC DOS, but MS had something up their sleeve: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DR-DOS#Competition_from_Microso... and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AARD_code
Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by bad_user on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @07:23PM (#1615947)

    Windows won because DOS was already everywhere. It wasn't
    the best product. I would argue OS/2 and Macintosh were 
    pretty significantly better.
No, they weren't.

The hardware requirements OS/2 were higher, Windows had better drivers support and provided better tools for developers. And the real battle was in '94 when IBM released OS/2 Warp. In '95 it was already game over.

People weren't using OS/2 for the same reasons they wouldn't go for Win NT 4. It was technically superior, but incompatible with what people wanted.

Win 95 had the same quality as Mac OS ... both were pieces of shit that got the job done, the difference being that you could get Win 95 for a better price and that it was future-proof (Win NT was already on sale for businesses).

IMHO, with Windows Microsoft only had 2 fuckups ... Windows ME and Vista. For all the other versions Microsoft just provided what consumers wanted.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by ido on Thursday August 19, 2010 @08:42AM (#1617169)
It seems a lot of people forget just how crummy mac os was before x.

I used OS 7.x for a good while, and it was generally speaking not better than its contemporary, windows 95.

In fact it might have been even worse, at least as far as multitasking and stability go.

Windows 98 SE was actually a fairly good system as long as you didn't overtax its somewhat limited multi-tasking ability & ran it on high quality hardware (far less crash prone than Mac OS 8.x)

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by jimbobimbo on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @03:20PM (#1615262)
>Windows won because DOS was already everywhere.

Actually previous poster made a good point with Vista problems - after a few years of bad press and Apple being a favorite, MS made a killing with Windows 7. Not for free.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by samatman on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @01:11PM (#1614803)
OS/2 leaps to mind...
Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by SkyMarshal on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @03:29PM (#1615300)
GEM OS was a contender too iirc.
Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by SkyMarshal on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @11:14PM (#1616395)
Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by neild on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @12:54PM (#1614744)
OS/2.
Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by loumf on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @01:58PM (#1614973)
OS/2 wasn't good enough, unfortunately. It was very expensive at the start -- and then there was OS/2 Warp which was ok, but not compelling. If the world were as web-enabled as it is now, it might have been fine -- the way it was -- you needed all of your software to work, and it didn't.

Even Windows 95 wasn't great (especially for programmers) -- it was Windows NT 4.0 that was good enough to use to get work done. It was a combination of being less crashy and having more native software available.

Re:Why Free Plans Don’t Work by stretchwithme on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @02:46PM (#1615167)
Definitely not good enough. OS/2 would not even install on some PCs from IBM without major effort.