Re:Ask HN: Best scifi of 2017? (Vernor Vinge/Larry Niven style)
by myhf on Saturday January 13, 2018 @03:46AM
(#16138789)
I liked how it drilled deep into themes that were important to the cultures in the story, which were very human cultures but not any specific Earth cultures. It was a glimpse into a small part of a large, coherent world.
But you have to like the characters or you can't get anywhere. People have described Stephen Baxter novels in similar ways, but I can't stand any of the characters.
Re:Ask HN: Best scifi of 2017? (Vernor Vinge/Larry Niven style)
by johnchristopher on Saturday January 13, 2018 @06:24PM
(#16141946)
That's interesting, I love Baxter's works and characters but finishing Ancillary's first book took me months and was painful. I liked the universe and the themes so I ended up reading the wikipedia summaries of the rest of the serie.
Re:Ask HN: Best scifi of 2017? (Vernor Vinge/Larry Niven style)
by johnchristopher on Sunday January 14, 2018 @06:38PM
(#16147252)
It just came to my mind that I like the manifold trilogy way more than the xelee cycle though.
I really really wanted to like this, but I just couldn't. Not my style unfortunately, but everyone keeps suggesting it so it's likely me that's the problem.