News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Leaving a startup that I co-own - How should I be... by RiderOfGiraffes on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @07:41AM (#1613826)
This is the situation that shares were intended to solve. They're not perfect, they're not ideal, but they do at least provide a way of thinking about the problem. This is simplistic and intended to give you a point of view from which to reason about it. It's not the end of the story.

Let's suppose there are 100 shares, and you each own 25 of them. You can't think in terms of the effort you've put in so far. That's sunk money/time and you need not to think about it at all. You need to think about the value of the company/idea/project as it is now.

And that's right now, not in two years time. You don't know what it will be worth in two years time. Given that you've lost your enthusiasm, in your heart of hearts you must think it's not going to be worth much in the future. If you honestly, truly believed it was worth pursuing then you'd take a day or two off to recharge, and then get stuck in again.

But you want to hedge against the million-to-one chance that this will all take off without you. So value your expectation of the company's worth.

With 50% chance, you think it's worth nothing.

With 30% chance you think in two years it will pay the bills, but only just. Company worth - $100k

With 15% chance it will be a really good, on-going business. Company worth - $400k

With 4% chance it will soar and be worth $1m.

With 1% chance it will really take off and be worth $7m.

Is that how you see it? Change the figures to match.

That makes the expected value ofthe company:

    0.5*0 + 0.3*100k + 0.15*400k + 0.04*1000k + 0.01*7000
  = 0 + 30k + 60k + 40k + 70k
  = 200k
So your share at the moment, based on this belief, is currently worth $50k. Each share is worth $2k, and you have 25.

Tell me - would you sell me your holding for $50k? If you snapped my hand off, then that valuation is too big. Are you really sure you wouldn't sell it to me for $50k?

Honestly?

So you need to adjust those figures down. Honestly, how much would you take for your 25%?

Now you want to walk away and leave your colleagues to take all the risk. The point is, they will continue to put time, effort and money into the venture. As they do so, they should be compensated, but you shouldn't. So they need to put in X and receive newly minted shares in return. Yes, your holding gets diluted, but the value of the company should be going up. The value of your holding doesn't change, so long as they're getting linear returns for their further investment.

Suppose they all put in an additional $10k. The company will then be worth $230k. They should each receive 5 newly minted shares, so there are 115 shares issued. You now hold a smaller percentage of a larger valued company. You have done nothing, and the value of your share holding reflects that.

Suppose they all put in another 6 months of work. How much is that worth? Based on what's happened so far it's a quarter of the time spent so far, so they should each get an additional 6 shares.

And so on.

Their proportion of the pot is increasing because they are continuing to put more in.

Now here's the kicker. You can trade your shares with them. If your valuation of the company is greater than theirs, you can put money in, getting shares in return based on the mutually agreed valuation (splitting the difference). On the other hand, if you think the company is going down but they don't, you can offer to sell back you shares.

So here's the question again - what would it take for me to buy the 25% from you and have you walk away completely?

Re:Ask HN: Leaving a startup that I co-own - How should I be... by legalhelp on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @10:23AM (#1614202)
I would definitely bite at the chance to pull $50k so I think you're right - that valuation would be too high.

I could walk away for $10k. That puts the company valuation at $40k. Before we brought on the last 2 owners, we talked about creating a separate agreement between me and the original founder where he pays me $9k back over time if the company makes money. So I think the $40k valuation is a good place to start.

Re:Ask HN: Leaving a startup that I co-own - How should I be... by kirpekar on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @03:26PM (#1615288)
Sorry, but why are you adding the probabilities? They are not mutually exclusive.

If there is a 1% chance that the company hits $7M, it's value is $70k -- that's it. It would have achieved all the other milestones you mention.

Re:Ask HN: Leaving a startup that I co-own - How should I be... by RiderOfGiraffes on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @04:27PM (#1615492)
That's only true if the other 99% of the time the company goes to the wall.

Take 100 companies and look at where they are in two years. 50 have gone to the wall, 40 end up worth $100k, and 10 end up worth $1m. The 100, in total, they are worth

  40*100k + 10*1,000k = 4,000k + 10,000k = 14,000k
The average value of the companies at the start is then 140k.

Now choose one of the companies. You don't know which it's going to be, but the expected value of the company you've chosen is 140k. The calculation I gave is the expected value, just as the "expectation" is computed in elementary probability. In the long run, you'll make 140k per company.

To compute the expected value, you find all the possibilities, compute the probability and value, multiply them, and add up the answer over all cases.

    expected_value = 0
    for case in possible_cases:

        prob = case.probability
        value = case.value
        expected_value += prob*value
or

    sum( [ case.probability * case.value for case in possible_outcome ] )
========

ADDED IN EDIT: If you seriously don't understand, and this doesn't help you, email me and we can work out where our understandings diverge, and pin down the calculation.