News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by weberc2 on Friday January 12, 2018 @05:21PM (#16136863)
> Claim 1

I respect that your opinion is that ISPs have a social responsibility to disclose this information so think tanks and academies don't have to find it. I'm curious if anyone thought to ask them, but that's neither here nor there. I don't generally expect businesses to provide data apart beyond that which is required by law, but I'll concede the point since it's unrelated to my claims.

> Claim 2: On this issue, I think it's helpful to discuss "critical studies" and related departments separately from the rest of "academia" and separately from the natural and mathematical sciences in particular. I don't think that the liberal bias in natural/math sciences has the same underlying causes OR the same long-term effects.

I agree, and I intended to. I should have done better, but I quickly authored that comment from my phone in the waiting room at the vet clinic.

> You also have to explain why political diversity is even important in the face of other forms of homogeneity. E.g., I'd rather a very liberal, very theoretical physics department hire a flaming liberal experimentalist than yet another theorist who happens to be conservative. The importance of political diversity in humanities and social sciences is obvious, but I don't see why science would suffer if all algebraists were libertarians...

Again, I don't mean to apply my "political diversity" quip to apolitical fields.

> My assertion is that if you want a politically diverse chemistry department, you have to 1) justify why that diversity is even necessary / more significant than other major problems; and then 2) probably also solve different underlying causes.

I agree, and I don't think political diversity is important in chemistry, since few chemistry topics are politically polarized.

> "Of course, I'm picking on the academy, but the same probably holds true for journalism." And also literally every other profession, from clergy to CEOs to career criminals. There's even a trite quote about it.

Probably some degree of political diversity is good for all fields, but it's uniquely critical for politically polarized epistemological fields.

There are no comments on this comment yet.