News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by jsoc815 on Friday January 12, 2018 @02:32PM (#16135574)
> You can buy commercial Internet uplink and link up your neighbours...

Thanks for this. I've been wondering about this for the last few years now. Guess the idea isn't completely nuts and will have to research further.

Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by grahamburger on Friday January 12, 2018 @07:05PM (#16137404)
I've been building https://startyourownisp.com - it's a (free) guide to starting a small ISP in your garage. I've been working with companies doing that for almost 15 years in the US.
Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by jsoc815 on Sunday January 14, 2018 @12:05PM (#16145024)
Many many 'thank you(s)' for that.
Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by dboreham on Friday January 12, 2018 @03:30PM (#16136038)
Alternatively go get a pile of money and prepare to set fire to it.

Source: did this for 10 years.

Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by mnzaki on Friday January 12, 2018 @03:48PM (#16136166)
I would be very interested to hear more about your experience dboreham! I'm assuming you mean you ran a small/local ISP and it was an overall loss?

What do you think of something like Hyperboria (https://hyperboria.net/) which is based on CJDNS, so there's no "ISP" really, but each peer sort of is a very small very local service provider to whoever they decide to peer with.

I was imagining some peers will charge other peers money to act as their gateway to the public network. Or maybe a bunch of people will pool their money and buy commercial network access

Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by dboreham on Saturday January 13, 2018 @12:30AM (#16138402)
Mesh networking is completely useless for providing anything other than last-ditch service. It originated in a) academia where it's a nice thing to tinker with and write PhD theses and b) in the military where having a network connection no matter how crappy can make the difference between life and death. It has no place imho in delivering any kind of service that someone would use day-to-day and certainly not one that anyone would pay for.

WISP networks are built with point-to-point links: the appropriate technology for delivering good QoS. Since radios and antennas are extremely cheap this is the way to go.

The rock you'll flounder upon is that you need to buy a pretty beefy connection to serve any number of customers (even 1). The cost of said connection in most places is quite high. This places a lower bound on the number of paying customers you need to break even. That number is somewhere around 100. This is before you factor in the cost of customer support, schlepping around on people's roofs, finding and negotiating leases on repeater locations, etc. The number of places where there is not a better competitive offering available to customers (or a high likelihood one will show up before you recoup your investment) is low.

Current wireless technology (and according to Shannon, any wireless technology we can imagine) has quite a low upper bound to throughput -- much lower than is achievable with coax for example. So you can't complete on speed with anyone except DSL and Satellite.

Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by otakucode on Friday January 12, 2018 @05:39PM (#16136970)
Be careful... in many places, it is illegal to offer a telecom service that competes. In many places, Comcast and similar have exclusivity contracts with the municipalities. And of course if you're going to be digging trenches and running lines, you need legal right-of-ways through properties or pole access rights to run lines on poles. In most places, they don't want any more cables run than are already present, so the only way to get those rights is through heavy political manipulation.

Also, if you live in a nice permissive place and you get all set up, don't be surprised if Comcast techs cut all of your lines and claim they didn't realize they shouldn't have done that. It wouldn't be the first time.

Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by briandear on Friday January 12, 2018 @06:50PM (#16137334)
See, THIS is what we should be fighting. NN is unnecessary if we have actual competition. Those exclusivity contracts, to me seem like Sherman Antitrust Act violations, since they are effectively creating cartel-like conditions to limit interstate commerce (i.e. commerce over "the wire.")
Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by ereyes01 on Friday January 12, 2018 @07:58PM (#16137614)
Digging trenches and laying out cables over entire neighborhoods is probably natural monopoly territory... i.e. it's not easily achievable without proper regulation / governemnt involvement. Therefore, another way to look at this is:

Proliferating internet access has been a big public/private partnership, and therefore we need NN to ensure that it continues to serve the public good. We shuld be fighting for the "public" part of the public/private partnership to not get fleeced.

Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by otakucode on Friday January 12, 2018 @10:03PM (#16138045)
Exactly. This is why Internet access is a public utility. No municipality wants 50 lines going pole to pole. I was curious about the idea of Internet as a public utility, so I did some research. I wanted to know what made people declare electricity, water, natural gas, etc to be regulated public utilities instead of just a free market setup. After reading some beautiful quotes from people opposing the establishment of such things (including many quotes from people certain that no reasonable person could ever want, much less need, a telephone in their own home when they could walk to a local store (because businesses were the only ones with legitimate need) and use theirs), I found that it comes down to one single question:

Does the benefit gained by society by having the service be ubiquitous amount to something greater than the damage done by the elimination of competition? If the answer is yes, then it should be made a public utility. I don't know how anyone could honestly argue that the private oligopoly setup we have now is so valuable to preserve that it provides more value to society than would ubiquitous Internet access. Just the fact that we could actually write laws on the assumption that people have Internet access would provide such tremendous benefit and enable us to get rid of some much duplicated junk as to be monumental.

Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by boon on Sunday January 14, 2018 @09:16AM (#16144319)
Who cares what the "local government" wants, what do the people want? The people could probably care less about huge lines being run if they can get their internet faster and cheaper.
Re:Harvard Study Shows Why Big Telecom Is Terrified of Commu... by jeffwilcox on Saturday January 13, 2018 @12:37AM (#16138424)
Our condo building in Seattle is one of the first to land a landmark experience... we have 3x coax cable providers in our building; per unit, we can select and move between the providers.

They are all playing in this space because they want the customers and revenue, but it took a long time for the gentlemen's agreements between the firms to start.

The installers for Comcast (the most recent to enter our building) were super professional, friendly and did a great job.

Hope other cities are able to fight down the exclusive contracts etc.