News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by tialaramex on Friday January 12, 2018 @01:41PM (#16135184)
Subscriptions is not generally a very useful metric. I would expect "Access" to mean that you would be able to sign up for and receive service, which might involve just a package arriving and you plug it in, but might mean people show up with a digger and spend a day running cable.

As illustration: The UK has some community owned projects which supply Internet access to otherwise under-served rural areas. The government ensures commercial suppliers don't run "spoiler" projects (e.g. when a community project announces they're coming to some village, the incumbent Telco can't suddenly remember they decided to run ultra-fast Internet to that village with a free introductory offer)

B4RN (Broadband For the Rural North but pronounced "Barn") is the most famous. They run dedicated fibre near to all the properties in a rural area, if you own some cottage in a little country village they're serving, the fibre probably runs in the grass outside your fence.

But people (probably volunteers since it's B4RN) need to come dig up your lawn and run cable to your cottage before you can actually use the service. B4RN charges a fair amount of money for this setup, although it's waived if you instead pay even more money to become a shareholder in their corporate entity. But still, the cottage would have "Access" once that fibre is outside, because B4RN have a commitment to do the install if you pay for it.

It's silly to say one cottage in a row doesn't have "Access" to B4RN's 1000Mbps symmetric Internet just because the old lady who lives there doesn't need the Internet. If you bought that cottage you could fork over the price of a Nintendo Switch and get Gigabit within a week or so.

Subscription _could_ be a good metric if we were arguing that Internet service is unacceptably expensive in specific regions and thus prices out the lower middle classes or working classes, but that's clearly not the focus of Vox's investigations.

You're right that it's important to classify "Broadband" and give some idea how fast that actually is. Certainly that's something that needs to be in the footnotes for such an article.

Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by jobu on Friday January 12, 2018 @02:15PM (#16135465)
> Subscription _could_ be a good metric if we were arguing that Internet service is unacceptably expensive in specific regions and thus prices out the lower middle classes or working classes, but that's clearly not the focus of Vox's investigations.

Affordability is actually the main point of 538's second article: "Lots Of People In Cities Still Can’t Afford Broadband" ( https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/lots-of-people-in-citie... )

However, that article is centered around the data for Washington D.C. and their retraction specifically talks about the data for D.C being incorrect.

Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Friday January 12, 2018 @02:55PM (#16135781)
... but then, there is no place on earth where you couldn't "sign up and recieve service" if you have a few billion to spare.
Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by tialaramex on Friday January 12, 2018 @07:32PM (#16137520)
From who?

I admit that "a few billion" which is clearly beyond what I was suggesting might open doors, but not by just signing up somewhere.

For example, the cable TV company offers Internet service to many people in my city, and indeed on my road. They put unsolicited advertisements through my door every week. But, despite the insistence that I could have "Super fast fibre-based Internet" tomorrow, in fact I can't, my building isn't connected and the owners of the building (an opaque off-shore property holding corporation) would need to sign off on work to change that, which they won't do even if I wanted it.

Now sure, I could buy all the flats in the building, then leverage control of those flats to force the current owner to sell me the building, and then I'd have the right to get that work done. That means now I'm paying maybe £2-5M to get their merely "super-fast" broadband to my flat in a major city. Short of your "billions" but not by so many orders of magnitude...

Or another example, for a few years the incumbent telco technically offered FTTP to any customer who could get their existing FTTC product, for a fee they'd work out what it cost them to run the extra cables and so on, add a percentage and if you agreed you'd pay that to get FTTP. The service was weakly advertised but immediately over-subscribed and it was effectively cancelled altogether without more than a handful of deployments. A few billion wouldn't do much about that I think, you'd need tens of billions to buy that incumbent telco and "change their minds" about the priority of such bespoke services that way.

Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Friday January 12, 2018 @11:48PM (#16138319)
> From who?

From someone?

> I admit that "a few billion" which is clearly beyond what I was suggesting might open doors, but not by just signing up somewhere.

Well, but what does "sign up somewhere" really mean? If you called a major telco and made it clear that you have a few billion to spend and you wanted a gigabit internet link, you don't think they would find a way? I mean, think Bill Gates calling ... you think he would have to do much more than order what he wants to get it delivered in a reasonable time frame?

> Now sure, I could buy all the flats in the building, then leverage control of those flats to force the current owner to sell me the building, and then I'd have the right to get that work done. That means now I'm paying maybe £2-5M to get their merely "super-fast" broadband to my flat in a major city. Short of your "billions" but not by so many orders of magnitude...

And really, you wouldn't have to do any of that. For one, you don't have to buy it, you simply have to tell them that you pay them a billion bucks to sign off on things, and secondly, the telco will happily do that for you.

But also, they wouldn't have to sign off on anything. The telco could just as well install an LTE cell just for you, or a laser link from across the street, ...

> A few billion wouldn't do much about that I think, you'd need tens of billions to buy that incumbent telco and "change their minds" about the priority of such bespoke services that way.

Erm ... what's the yearly profits of that telco? What's a few billion in comparison to that? You don't think they'd take a substantial increase in profits for a few days of work for some of their technicians?

Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by ghaff on Friday January 12, 2018 @03:58PM (#16136239)
You don't need to make such an extreme argument. I'm not sure what dollar threshold I would use but I don't think I'd get much of an argument saying that, if it costs $10K to get a hookup somewhere, the average household in that area doesn't really have access to broadband.
Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by mynameisvlad on Friday January 12, 2018 @03:08PM (#16135890)
We both know this is a disingenuous argument, because average households don't have a few billion to spare.
Re:We Used Broadband Data We Shouldn’t Have by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Friday January 12, 2018 @11:55PM (#16138330)
And neither do many households have a few thousand or even a few hundred bucks to spare, which is precisely why the argument "available access is if you could sign up" that I was responding to doesn't work. There is no place where you couldn't get broadband internet, and in most places within developed countries for a lot less than a billion, but that doesn't mean households could actually reasonably afford it. You would at least have to specify some price limit for availability.