News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'The desire to have a child never goes away': The Involun... by everyone on Friday January 12, 2018 @01:23PM (#16135024)
I most cases say, mammals have a desire for sex. Also instinctual love for their offspring and a motivation to feed, care for, and teach them. Humans certainly have all that..

But that does still not tally with a pre-meditated rational conscious desire to have children. We certainly wouldnt expect to see that in other mammals.

I think the type of conscious decision to have kids discussed in this article may be a socio-cultural phenomenon.

There are documented cases of stone-age level people who had not actually made the connection between sex and resultant children. We are not certainly imbued from birth with knowledge like that.

Re:'The desire to have a child never goes away': The Involun... by dragonwriter on Friday January 12, 2018 @01:58PM (#16135338)
> I think the type of conscious decision to have kids discussed in this article may be a socio-cultural phenomenon.

Survival of memes and survival of genes are a little different, but not entirely independent; once you have a concept of the relation of sex to reproduction (which huma societies demonstrably have had for quite a long time, in general, even if there are some primitive exceptions), a community (and it's ideas) is much less likely to becomem influential, or even survivez , if it doesn't value reproduction unless it's somehow in a symbiotic relation with a community that does; this may be somewhat less true today (an interesting discussion), but in most of human history this would have been a big deal.

Also, that aside, it serves as a rationalozation of the lower level drives discussed earlier, and a social value framework that includes elemenrs that provide rationalizations that enable a feeling of understanding of lower-level drives provides a kind of (strictly speaking, fallacious, but that's not important to it's value in promoting acceptance) validation for the whole framework.

Re:'The desire to have a child never goes away': The Involun... by dwaltrip on Friday January 12, 2018 @01:58PM (#16135332)
Unless the consciously stated desire is an ad-hoc rationalization of the underlying drives.

I agree with you there are also likely strong cultural influences which are unfolding mostly separately from any genetic dynamics.