Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker
by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:19PM
(#16128577)
Sure.
Citizens United is also terrible.
I agree, but that is a clear result of the 1st Amendment. And you get lots of people angry if you start to question whether the 1st Amendment is a great idea.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker
by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:40PM
(#16128755)
No, it isn't. It's a result of a surprising and non-obvious legal doctrine established in a case regarding the 14th Amendment.
Citizens United itself was a 5-4 decision, so it's fair to say that CU was also a far-from-clear result.
I am not sure what you are really arguing here. The 14th Amendment portion of Citizens United is not the part of the case that has relevancy to this discussion. Overturning that portion would still allow Thiel's actions since he was acting as an individual. It would have a greater chance of effecting the EFF's action in that regard.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker
by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:23PM
(#16129043)
> The 14th Amendment portion of Citizens United is not the part of the case that has relevancy to this discussion
The Citizens United decision rests on Corporate Personhood. Corporate Personhood was established in a case testing the limits of the 14th amendment.
Citizens United was a case that addressed two issues. There was the 14th Amendment issue of corporate personhood and the 1st Amendment issue of whether money equals speech. Both of those had been applied separately before but this decision unified the two. You are focusing on the 14th Amendment portion while I was referencing the 1st Amendment portion, which is also likely the less controversial portion.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker
by dragonwriter on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:25PM
(#16129056)
“Corporate personhood" is the whole point of the corporate form, and predates the US.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker
by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:00PM
(#16129239)
As does "freedom of speech", I guess. But both of those things mean something more specific in the context of US constitutional law, of course. It's that more specific meaning to which I'm referring. Sorry for the lack of precision.
Anyways, my only point was that Citizens United was not exactly a clear or obvious application of the First Amendment, and offering up the integral role of cases involving the Fourteenth Amendment as examples.
I guess merely mentioning that the decision was 5-4 would've been enough and prevented this now rather long thread.
I am also not speaking about a moral difference, I am speaking about a legal difference. How can you allow someone to spend $X on something with the logic that money equals speech but not allow someone to spend $X multiplied by a million on the same thing?