News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:46PM (#16128231)
Well "shutting down a garbage site for doing something bad" is quite different from "shutting down a site over frivolous complaints".

You'll note that Gawker lost their case, and Mother Jones won.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by untog on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:51PM (#16128293)
Right, but in both cases a billionaire got to choose what qualifies as "something bad". That's the "principle" part I'm getting at here that worries me.

Let's not kid ourselves - Thiel did not fund this lawsuit because he was deeply concerned about the fate of Hulk Hogan. He did it because of the coverage he'd received from Valleywag, which, let's be clear, included outing him! I'm not saying he's wrong to be aggrieved. But the idea that, if you have enough money, you can shut down whatever media organisation you want... that concerns me.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:52PM (#16128309)
My point is the courts decide what's bad. That's why the fact mother Jones won in court in the end is significant here.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by untog on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:56PM (#16128359)
Right, but from the article:

> They filed the suit in Bonneville County, Idaho, and asked for damages of up to $74,999—exactly $1 under the amount at which the lawsuit could have been removed to federal court. That ensured the case would be decided by jurors from the community where his company is the biggest employer and the sponsor of everything from the minor league ballpark to the Fourth of July fireworks.

The court system is not immune to problems.

> Since then, Mother Jones and our insurance company have had to spend at least $2.5 million defending ourselves. That’s money we can’t get back, since Idaho doesn’t have an anti-SLAPP statute that might open the door for recovering attorney’s fees in a case like this.

VanderSloot did not need to win against Mother Jones, he just needed to bankrupt them. And he nearly did. That this particular attempt failed does not mean the principle is not a dangerous one. In many ways the court decision is secondary to the enormous costs of defending yourself legally.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:59PM (#16128401)
Sounds like a good reason to have a federal anti-SLAPP law.

Also, if they only wanted 75k in damages why didn't MJ agree to pay that and save themselves 2.5 million?

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by untog on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:01PM (#16128425)
> Also, if they only wanted 75k in damages why didn't MJ agree to pay that and save themselves 2.5 million?

Presumably because that's like waving a "free $75k available here" flag to anyone else who feels like suing them next week, and the week after that?

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:03PM (#16128446)
Anti-SLAPP laws have the same problem as "regulation via judiciary" -- by the time the law becomes useful, the damage is already done. If you go bankrupt defending yourself, suing under a SLAPP law doesn't help. Also, the barrier for proving you shouldn't be SLAPPed is far lower than the already low barrier for civil damages, so there's some question as to whether this even solves the problem.

Our civil justice system needs to be cheaper and more accessible. It shouldn't be possible to wage economic war on a company or individual via the judiciary.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:08PM (#16128490)
Attorneys can take your case pro bono and then sue for wages later with anti-SLAPP, iirc. And it's much cheaper to file the anti-SLAPP than to defend against the suit.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:16PM (#16128548)
Well, sure, and a billionaire can donate billions of dollars to help defend you. Or you could crowd-fund $5 million. Or...

But designing a justice system around "maybe you'll find a charitable person willing to help" seems like a bad idea.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:25PM (#16128628)
Sounds like the Nirvana fallacy in action. Unless you have a better proposal, complaining about how some improvement isn't perfect doesn't do anything.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:37PM (#16128735)
> Sounds like the Nirvana fallacy in action. Unless you have a better proposal

Pointing out problems with the current system is not a logical fallacy, and having a working solution in-hand is not a pre-requisite to observing the existence of problems.

Also, accusing me of using the Nirvana fallacy while also accusing me of not providing an alternative policy is literally a contradiction...

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:44PM (#16128783)
You're critiquing my proposal for a new federal law.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:46PM (#16128790)
I haven't claimed there's a perfect solution. I haven't even claimed there is a solution. I'm just pointing out that your proposal is not a solution.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by eropple on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:19PM (#16128574)
Mother Jones winning is the exception, not the rule, and plenty of outlets can't afford a legal fight. Those that can can-and-do (as Mother Jones did) are usually severely hampered in their ability to actually serve the people by dealing with barratrous claims.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:22PM (#16128595)
Again, that has exactly zero relevance to both cases cited here.

Why cite an exception yet no typical examples while making your case?

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by jdoliner on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:58PM (#16128382)
No Thiel got to choose what qualifies for a court to hear. The court decided what qualifies as "something bad." There's a big difference. It does kinda suck the amount of money it takes to bring something to court, but that's the world we live in. You still have to win the case.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by eropple on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:23PM (#16128605)
This isn't getting enough attention.

Being able to pick the venue of your grievance means a lot.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwaway2048 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:23PM (#16129686)
you dont have to win the case if the defender goes bankrupt first.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:49PM (#16128275)
Yeah, but unlike Mother Jones, most political bloggers don't have millions of dollars to wage a multi-year war.

The general concern is that money provides one the ability to silence other people's speech.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:54PM (#16128345)
I agree this is an issue, but just because some people can't afford to defend themselves doesn't make what Thiel did wrong. You'll note Gawker was fully able to fund their defense.

If Thiel had did this against a smaller site that gave up without having its day in court that would be a different matter.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:00PM (#16128414)
untog ended their up-thread comment with a pre-emptive answer to exactly this sentiment:

>> Personally, I'm concerned that the individual factors of this case (i.e. Gawker being Gawker) will overshadow the principle at stake, which feels a lot more important than a gossip site.

Thiel isn't on trial in this thread, but our justice system perhaps is.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:09PM (#16128498)
What principle are they defending?
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:15PM (#16128544)
Free speech. And, in particular, the chilling effect that's possible due to how our civil justice system is defined.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:26PM (#16128636)
I assume you don't mean the free speech of Thiel to fund any lawsuit he wants to?
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:47PM (#16128799)
No, he's one of the few people whose free speech I'm not terribly concerned about. (Don't be confused: I think he should have the right to express his opinion, I just don't think that right is in any jeopardy).

I mean the free speech of anyone who doesn't have $N million needed to fend off a civil suit. If cases like this and the MJ one become common-place, there's a very real risk of chilling effect.

Incidentally, I think it's probably possible to allow Thiel the ability to sue Gawker into the ground without also having a system where genuinely legal free speech is reserved for people who can afford massive financial risk. So there's absolutely no reason for you to disagree with me just because you think Thiel in on the right side of the Gawker issue...

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:53PM (#16128837)
I think that's important as well, but both the Gawker and MJ cases are entirely irrelevant because they both were able to defend themselves.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:56PM (#16128847)
By the same argument, patent trolls are NBD. Except, of course, we know for a fact that lots of people are extorted into paying BS fees because they can't afford to go to court.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:07PM (#16128912)
If you tried to make the case that patent trolls are a big problem because they extort large fees from people, it would be appropriate to talk about cases where people settled and paid "BS fees". If you cite one case where the plaintiff won, and another where they lost in court, you aren't making that case very well because you haven't discussed any actual cases of the alleged harm.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:10PM (#16128942)
Sorry, in one thread you're suggesting anti-SLAPP laws and in another (this thread) you're apparently claiming that SLAPP doesn't happen.

I'm confused.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:16PM (#16128985)
I'm not claiming that at all - if you look above I said I acknowledge this is an issue. It's just not relevant to the cases in the OP comment.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:28PM (#16129070)
Yes, and as I already pointed out, the root comment states:

>>>>>> Personally, I'm concerned that the individual factors of this case (i.e. Gawker being Gawker) will overshadow the principle at stake, which feels a lot more important than a gossip site.

We are discussing principles and problems that are larger than just these two cases. That's the entire thesis of the comment that started this thread.

Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by ikeboy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:42PM (#16129154)
It cited another case as representative of the real issue, which wasn't.
Re:Peter Thiel submits bid for Gawker by throwawayjava on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:03PM (#16129260)
MJ was offered as an example of a suit that was filed despite the fact that the speech was clearly legally protected, and where the cost of the suit was rather outrageous despite this fact. It establishes a) that people sue maliciously even when they know their suit is baseless; and b) that these suits are none-the-less expensive to defend.

It's fairly obvious that (b) is concerning, and also fairly obvious that it takes an actual suit to put a price tag on this problem. That's why the MJ case was presented.

But all of this is obvious and explained in the comments above, so this is getting very pedantic, and I don't see a) what point you're trying to make, or b) how that point is at all relevant to the overall thesis of the root comment.