IP data retention, on the other hand, will be interesting. On the one hand, law enforcement wants to have ISPs and companies to track and remember those, for future investigations. But on the other hand, privacy advocates want that kind of data to not be stored at all.
Here's the UK's ICO guidance for what you can process, as far as I can tell they've got no lawful basis for trying to match a user's IP address to a company without the user asking them to.
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...
It seems like you're saying that analyzing IP addresses a user connected from in order to determine their likely employer is against the UK's GDPR guidance, even if the data is released only in aggregate (but that it might be fine to keep that IP data since perhaps there are other uses for it which would be legitimate). Is that your understanding?
This page gives it some context:
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...
Further down are the 6 reasons for processing.
We know the first 5 don't apply:
consent - there's no consent
contract - it's not necessary to provide the Q&A answer site
Legal obligation - there's no legal obligation
Vital interests - nope
Public task - nope
So what it falls under is "Legitimate interests", SO want to use a user's IP address, process it to add company name, store that and then use that data for profiling their customers to serve them ads.One of the problems for SO is that further down they go into this a bit more and there's a few key questions:
Would individuals expect this processing to take place?
Are some of the individuals concerned likely to object?
Are you able to stop the processing at any time on request?
Which I would think would be answer No, Yes, No. Which seems to indicate that there's some problems with SO's approach.> (b) 'processing of personal data' ('processing') shall mean any operation or set of operations which is performed upon personal data, whether or not by automatic means, such as collection, recording, organization, storage, adaptation or alteration, retrieval, consultation, use, disclosure by transmission, dissemination or otherwise making available, alignment or combination, blocking, erasure or destruction;
(Directive 95/46/EC)
All IPs are personal data (even if they are dynamicly assigned) if I read [1] correctly (Not a lawyer and there is most likely something I miss).
[1] http://curia.europa.eu/juris/celex.jsf?celex=62014CJ0582&lan...
Even if they aren't, I still wonder that if they're checking everyones IP addresses against that database, essentially sharing our access of SO with a third-party, would it still be an inappropriate use of personally identifiable information?
Quoting their website, "The organization name is available for about 40% of corporate, government, and educational networks."
As it offers goods and services to EU citizens, it has to operate according to GDPR as far as I understand it.
And it does do sales in the EU, there are plenty of SO jobs being advertized (and paid for) in the EU.
It seems like a massive invasion of privacy (which I guess lots of websites are doing).
But to me that SO can so casually mention the mass surveillance and privacy invasion they're doing without thinking that there's anything wrong with it is the worst part of it.
I certainly never knowingly agreed that they could check my IP address and then try and figure out what company I work at from it.
EDIT: Once GDPR is live in the EU, I think it might be interesting to see if I can challenge this privacy invasion and inappropriate use of personally identifying data. I guess we'll see if GDPR has any actual teeth in this instance.