News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by Afforess on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:15AM (#16121540)
I suspect that as we come to better understand genetics, we (as a society) are going to be more and more uncomfortable with the findings that we uncover. Physics and mathematics have made it long since clear that the universe is deterministic, that all the answers lie in the genes and atoms and equations we are made up of. The implications of this are dire - our society is built on exactly the opposite foundations; law and order assumes the criminals are acting of free will, education assumes all students are equal, and societal success rests on the notion that all men are equal. None of this is true. All of the implications can be twisted to serve our worst, or our best instincts.

Some will take this study to mean Homosexuality is a disease, to be cured. Others will reject it, to say the science is not yet "in", the study needs replications, meta-studies are needed to verify and corroborate it. We should embrace it, and say that it is good we are not a monoculture, embrace mutation and variation. To be human is to be different.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by gh02t on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:26AM (#16121584)
Eh, I don't know if you want to take it quite that far. Your genes might predispose you towards one path or another, but there is still free will involved. Complex sociological events like someone committing a criminal act can't just be reduced to "their genes made them do it." There are other factors involved and they are far more complex than what can be reduced to simple genetics.

I think sexual orientation is probably an inherent trait in most people, but to say something like educational success is just a result of genetics and not other factors like teachers, parents etc is simplistic.

Not to mention that the universe is hardly deterministic. Chaos theory and quantum physics show quite clearly that randomness and unpredictability are fundamental.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by moosinho on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:10AM (#16122197)
It is a common misconception that Chaos theory and Quantum Mechanics show that universe is random. Chaos theory is a perfectly deterministic theory that basically means fragility to initial conditions. Quantum Mechanics, at least in Copenhagen interpretation does imply that the universe is random. But there at least 2 more, perfectly deterministic interpretations that make exactly the same predictions as the non-deterministic one. These are Many Worlds Interpretation and Bohmian Mechanics.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by gh02t on Sunday January 14, 2018 @10:43PM (#16148344)
Chaos theory doesn't imply randomness, it implies unpredictability. Hyper sensitivity to initial conditions means you can't reliably predict the exact outcome, because it's impossible to observe all the relevant initial conditions accurately enough. I can't, for example, predict the trajectory of a actual double-rod pendulum except at fairly short time intervals even though the governing equations are known, because practically I cannot measure the initial conditions precisely enough. I would argue that even if you could write a master equation to predict human behavior perfectly it'd likely either be so sensitive to initial conditions it'd be useless or have so many initial conditions that you wouldn't be able to determine them all.

I guess I'm not super expert on QM or some of its different interpretations, but from our point of view there's not a whole lot of difference between multiple universes and actual randomness is there?

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by brucephillips on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:35AM (#16121625)
> Your genes might predispose you towards one path or another, but there is still free will involved.

Genetic determinism is not the same as free will. Our genes don't determine everything, but together with our environment, they do.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by exclusiv on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:12AM (#16121756)
I believe in free will but I think it's possible it doesn't exist at a 100% level in practice as you allude to with genes, environment, history, brain chemistry, etc. If you imagined free will as Madden football awareness ratings, some will be close to 100 but many others will be a lot lower.

So sane people aren't incapable of making the right choice but they are incapable of doing as reliably as others across multiple scenarios over time because there are a lot of other factors at play than being human and having free will.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by gh02t on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:41AM (#16121653)
They don't determine everything is my point. Environment paired with genetics has a strong (sometimes overwhelming) influence on the decisions you make for sure, and they make many decisions harder or easier, but you still maintain the ability to choose. Free will isn't the ability to make any choice without external influences, it's just that you have a choice at all.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by brucephillips on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:44AM (#16121668)
What are you calling a choice? Are you simply saying that people act? Then yes, that's of course tautologically true.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by md224 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:01AM (#16121726)
I think we just have an unbridgeable gap of beliefs here: one of you believes that they are the ultimate author of their own words and actions, that their experience of making decisions should be taken as strong evidence that they are in fact making decisions, and that any theory that denied this fact would be in need of revision. The other believes that the scientific enterprise has conclusively disproven the possibility of actual free will, and therefore agency is merely an illusion.

Lately I’ve been siding with the first stance, but I can understand both. It comes down to the strength of your faith that Science understands (for the most part) all of the essential features of reality, and also your trust in your immediate experience.

It’s a tough question.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by gh02t on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:11AM (#16121755)
Not quite, at least in my case. Like I said I do think that people mostly are the sum of their parts. It's just that for me, the possibility that anyone can escape their circumstances makes it irrational (as well as immoral) to totally exclude a class of people based on characteristics like genetics. The ultimate debate is on sociological reflexivity, and I don't believe that someone's behavior can ever be totally deterministically predicted, analogous to how certain physical phenomena like radioactive decay are truly random.

Which is not what the other comment was saying I don't think, but the parent comment was.

Edit to add: and even if human behavior was actually a deterministic function of their history it'd surely be a chaotic system. I can't say I really see much difference in that case.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by gh02t on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:06AM (#16121739)
It's more that I'm saying humans have agency (in the philosophical meaning of the word). You can't know with 100% certainty what a person will do, even with perfect knowledge of everything about them. You can predict with very high confidence, but never certainty, because people can (and occasionally do) act randomly.

That said, I do believe that people are more or less the sum of their parts and I accept that genetics are especially important. However, there are always people who defy expectations. I just don't except that it is a totally deterministic connection.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by peteretep on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:58AM (#16121943)
> They don't determine everything is my point

What else affects agency? I think you have to look to religion, rather than science, to come to any conclusion other than human actions being essentially deterministic.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by ethbro on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:24AM (#16121573)
The universe can be deterministic and still practically unknowable.

Chaos theory: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by justinjlynn on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:26AM (#16121590)
Here's a fun one. A transcendental real number which is not computable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaitin%27s_constant
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by pm on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:38AM (#16121638)
None of us are dealt an equal hand in life. Having a genetic predisposition that advantages or disadvantages someone does not absolve them of the responsibility of their actions. If we were unchanging machines, that may not be the case, but it's much more complex than we give it credit for, and the debate is unlikely to be resolved anytime soon.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by avodonosov on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:24AM (#16121572)
> Physics and mathematics have made it long since clear that the universe is deterministic

Have they?

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by 8bitsrule on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:36AM (#16121629)
As I recall, the theologists held similarly self-promoting illusions centuries ago. I also recall that early scientists declared that the universe is a clockwork. I also recall that Lord Kelvin, in the late 1800s, declared that physics was all finished except for a few minor details.

The physical universe is not a complete mystery. To the extent that certain phenomena can be agreed to procede from other phenomena in a repeatable fashion, there is indeed reason to celebrate. As many wise men have pointed out, however, we are very small and the universe is very great. The extent of that which we do not understand at all is good reason to suspect that we must continue to deliberately blind ourselves if we are to keep patting ourselves on the back.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by tclancy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:34AM (#16121623)
Sure, John Calvin told us so. And then we rejected it. And then it became a sure thing again. And then not . . . and now here we are.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by itronitron on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:47AM (#16121675)
Can the universe be deterministic if our knowledge of whether the universe is deterministic is not deterministic?
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by mikekij on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:26AM (#16121586)
At the macro level.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by fasquoika on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:32AM (#16121614)
No
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by _joe on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:30AM (#16121609)
Physics gave up being "deterministic" (in the sense you used the term in) about 120 years ago.

And mathematics is just a convenient tool with which we describe reality, no one would seriously think today that our math is deeply inscribed in the essence of reality as Galileo thought.

Apart from this, and the fact that the paper shows a very weak statistical significance, I agree fully with your last statement.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by wyager on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:33AM (#16121618)
> no one would seriously think today that our math is deeply inscribed in the essence of reality

This is straight up wrong; most physicists I know, regardless of subdiscipline, basically agree on some variation of the idea that reality is somehow underpinned by algebraic structures.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by excalibur on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:41AM (#16121654)
Reality is just a convenient tool with which we can discern mathematics.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by brucephillips on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:33AM (#16121616)
> the paper shows a very weak statistical significance

How so? The p values are quite low.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by tempay on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:07AM (#16121981)
They're not low enough to account for the look elsewhere effect[1] (known by a different name in this field, but the idea is the same). In this case they look at 500,000 measurements so finding p-values of 10⁻⁵/10⁻⁶ is expected.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Look-elsewhere_effect

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by curun1r on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:03AM (#16122173)
Not just genetics, but also our gut microbiome. The studies linking depression and other thinking to our gut bacteria raise some profound moral implications.

I've had really interesting conversations with some of the gay people I know where I've urged them to at least start thinking about what would happen if science found a biological or genetic basis for homosexuality. If human sexuality can be altered with a probiotic, targeted antibiotic or gene therapy, the LGBT community should be prepared for the renewed attack on their way of life that would bring. Just because they intuitively consider it part of their identity doesn't mean that it is biologically so. Science isn't going to avoid investigating or finding these kinds of things, no matter how much opinion shifts towards acceptance of non-majority sexual preferences.

I can also envision a world in which increased understanding of the mechanics of our sexuality poses some interesting moral questions and scenarios. What if all sexual preferences are governed by these mechanics, not just gender? Even straight people have a wide variety of preferences when it comes to race, body type and other physical characteristics. Could surreptitiously trying to alter someone's preferences be considered rape in much the same way that using GHB to bypass consent currently is? Could we have a world where gene therapies to increase compatibility become part of marital counseling? Might 23andme.com become the world's best online dating site? Might people in cultures with arranged marriages start forming the arrangements pre-birth and then selecting embryos for IVF based on the compatibility of their offspring?

This field of study offers so many really interesting /r/WritingPrompts for near-future science fiction writers. So many of our institutions, customs and culture revolve around the propagation of the species that demystifying it could really turn society on its head in some interesting ways.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by red75prime on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:10AM (#16122196)
> law and order assumes the criminals are acting of free will

It doesn't really matter if there's no "free will", while a behavior of an individual can be approximated as a behavior of rational agent who properly reacts to an expectation of positive or negative consequences.

If a person can react rationally, then it is rational to disincentivize them. If they can't, then it is rational to move them to a psychiatric hospital, where they'll have better chances at fixing the problem knowing exact genetical causes.

The same as now.

> To be human is to be different.

Within Overton window. No one is going to embrace pedophiles anytime soon.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by nikolay on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:08AM (#16121743)
Here's what I don't get: we glorify the Theory of Evolution and science in general, but at the same time we let politics and activism get involved. So, which of these is true, at the end, when we remove politics from our decision: homosexuality is a) "nature (not a disorder)", b) "nature (disorder)", or c) "nurture"? In addition to removing politics, let's remove emotions before answering. Science doesn't and shouldn't care if its conclusions are easy to digest or what we expect.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by chongli on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:19AM (#16121552)
Call me naïve, but I'm optimistic. All of those assumptions you ascribe to society fall under the umbrella of the just world fallacy. The sooner that thing dies, the better.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by ISL on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:27AM (#16121593)
Evolutionary-biologist Will Provine's perspective on free will helped very much to inform my own:

https://evolutionnews.org/2015/09/william_provine/

(Edit: this is apparently an intelligent-design advocacy publication, but it is telling how much his opponents respected him. Provine would have been touched. Here's another link, for context: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/p/ptb/6959004.0007.003/--william-...)

He had a lot of thoughtful and kind things to say, and a lot of courage to back it up. Have a gander at some of his work if it piques your interest.

Thanks for your post -- it led me to the news that he had passed away. He had so long surpassed the odds on his specific guaranteed-to-recur cancer that I almost believed him to be invulnerable.

Thank you, Will. We lead best by example; yours was superb.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by brucephillips on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:28AM (#16121602)
> law and order assumes the criminals are acting of free will, education assumes all students are equal, and societal success rests on the notion that all men are equal

None of this is true. We would still imprison those who break the law, despite a deterministic universe, for quarantine, if nothing else.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by Borealid on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:48AM (#16121681)
We punish for dissuasion. Some who would break the law in the absence of punishment will "choose" (however one wants to interpret that word in a fully deterministic world) not to do so because of the possibility and cost of punishment.

Even punishments such as fines still make sense in a fully deterministic world, and in one where there is no societal desire to be "fair" or give people what they "deserve".

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by ProAm on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:21AM (#16121561)
> Physics and mathematics have made it long since clear that the universe is deterministic

Except none of them have any idea whats really going on...

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by RoboticWater on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:34AM (#16121622)
Compared to what? Yes, we can rest on the technicality that science is only an ever-expanding and ever-solidifying theory, but can't–by fallibility of perception–ever reach perfect truth. So what though. What else do we have to go on?

Regardless, the fact that we've made any strides at all within these fields is proof of determinism. If not 100% determinism, then enough to dispel notions of a "just world."

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by ISL on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:28AM (#16121600)
We know a lot of things. We simply focus all of our effort on the things we do not yet understand.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by 8bitsrule on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:41AM (#16121656)
Not according to Thomas Kuhn, we don't.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by dwaltrip on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:22AM (#16122040)
That's a misreading of Kuhn. He believed in scientific progress -- he says so explicitly.
Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by 8bitsrule on Friday January 12, 2018 @11:17PM (#16138260)
I was responding to the statement that "We simply focus all of our effort on the things we do not yet understand."

Kuhn (short summary) pointed out that paradigms arise which, after a time, cause scientists that have 'bought in' to resist attempts to modify them. Many scientists get 'stuck' in the current paradigm and pooh-pooh attempts to modify them. The history of science demonstrates this over and over ... EG Wegener, EG Clovis.

Yep, Kuhn recognizes progress. His major point is that progress doesn't come from the orthodox establishment.

Re:Two genes in Chromosomes 13 and 14, linked to Homosexuality by dwaltrip on Saturday January 13, 2018 @08:44PM (#16142383)
Ah I see. My bad, I assumed you were talking about the first part.