I'd actually go a step farther and FIRE anyone who regularly works a lot of overtime -- for exactly the same reason.
As far as I'm concerned, sillycone valley can have the rockstars. It will keep them out of my hair so that I can get things done.
I'd rather hire someone who doesn't spend all of their spare time programming because they're going to be more rested and fresh when it comes to their work programming. Spending time with family, outdoor activities, cultural events, hell even reading and not being in front of a computer are all vital to the brain.