News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland by w00pla on Tuesday August 17, 2010 @11:18AM (#1611345)
Firstly, a lot of studies (esp. in the USA) shows that corporal punishment have negative outcomes. This is because they do not control for other variables (such as socio-economic circumstances). Poorer parents often hit their kids more (and many studies do make a distinction between parental abuse and responsible punishment).

This is the same as the “powerlines causes cancer” research (people living near powerlines tend to be poorer and more prone to cancer). And powerlines is not even an ideological viewpoint!

The problem is that I can give you a slew of papers saying that “corporal punishment has no detrimental effects” and you can give me another slew saying it has detrimental effects. Such internet discussions will not go anywhere (the same as with the death penalty or gun rights). Perhaps I was wrong to bring this up in YCNews (since this is not the forum for such debates).

In any case, in the country of Singapore they have less crime and fewer problems that 99% of Western countries. Yet they have very strict laws (including corporal and capital punishment for drug offences).

EDIT: The original point I wanted to make was this:

In the USA, tough punishment only comes after the criminal has firmly established his bad behaviour. Any pet owner knows that at that stage it is the most difficult to change set behaviour.

You have silly things such as three strikes laws. Why? The third time that behaviour is fixed.

If that same person were punished severely for his first crime (however minor) he would think twice about breaking the law.

That is how it works in Singapore - the first crime is punished hard, and the behaviour doesn't re-occur.

Re:Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland by rdtsc on Tuesday August 17, 2010 @12:09PM (#1611514)
> capital punishment for drug offences ...

> the first crime is punished hard, and the behaviour doesn't re-occur.

Of course it "doesn't re-occur" -- the person is already dead the second time around ;-)

Re:Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland by w00pla on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @07:48AM (#1613836)
How many lives do you think one drug dealer ruin before they are caught?
Re:Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland by speleding on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @09:33AM (#1614046)
How many lives would he ruin if drugs were not illegal?
Re:Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland by w00pla on Thursday August 19, 2010 @07:54AM (#1617085)
Making drugs legal (contrary to popular internet belief) does not make them less addictive or less harmful.
Re:Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland by jazzdev on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:10PM (#1621107)
It absolutely makes them less harmful because the government will no longer harm you.
Re:Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland by rdtsc on Wednesday August 18, 2010 @10:03AM (#1614133)
Well I guess we'll never know ...