You're right in all points (almost[1]), but those are mostly technical issues that can be solved with some work[2], except for two points :
- the bandwidth problem is real, but there is no more technological limitation[3], it's merely a commercial problem: client have no use for huge uplinks, then providers don't sell them. It's a bit of a chicken & egg problem.
- the monetization problem is the root of all sins in that case …
[1] on the client versioning & patching side, you underestimate the complexity of distributing a web client, with CDN, browser caches and clients who never reload their page, you can also end up with a lot of client lagging behind in updates.
[2] and centralized system also have their own issues (scaling anyone ?)
[3] ADSL was asymmetric because the asymmetry widened the reception bandwidth, which would otherwise be too low. With optical fibers, you don't have such limitations.
- the bandwidth problem is real, but there is no more technological limitation[3], it's merely a commercial problem: client have no use for huge uplinks, then providers don't sell them. It's a bit of a chicken & egg problem.
- the monetization problem is the root of all sins in that case …
[1] on the client versioning & patching side, you underestimate the complexity of distributing a web client, with CDN, browser caches and clients who never reload their page, you can also end up with a lot of client lagging behind in updates.
[2] and centralized system also have their own issues (scaling anyone ?)
[3] ADSL was asymmetric because the asymmetry widened the reception bandwidth, which would otherwise be too low. With optical fibers, you don't have such limitations.