News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Review our webapp: AirDropper by ams6110 on Monday August 16, 2010 @07:12PM (#1609626)
I genuinely wish you the best, but this does not seem to solve any problem that I can see.

If I want a file from someone, the easiest thing is for me to email him and say "send me file X" and he will reply with file X attached.

If he's hesitant to send file X because it contains sensitive information, he can encrypt it first.

If the file is sensitive, I have to decide whether I trust the person asking for it, but assuming I do, I also have to decide if I trust AirDropper and Dropbox? If I don't, then I encrypt the file anyway, at which point I might as well just email it directly.

Re:Ask HN: Review our webapp: AirDropper by jesselamb on Monday August 16, 2010 @07:52PM (#1609731)
You make a fair point. I'd say though, putting the important issue of trust aside for a second, it's not that we don't solve any problem, but that we solve a problem for which there are already other solutions. And in practice those solutions have disadvantages.

Taking file encryption as an example, you can certainly encrypt a file before sending it, but that depends on the sophistication of the sender. They may not be familiar with how to encrypt a file. And if they are, it's kind of a hassle dealing with encrypted files on both ends. You have to transmit the password in some separate medium from the file itself, and now you have to decide whether to keep both the encrypted and unencrypted versions. It's friction that our solution obviates.

Likewise, you can send an email attachment for non-sensitive files, but every email provider has differing file size caps. We're still testing the limits of our service, but we've already successfully handled files more than double Gmail's size caps, which are among the highest in the industry. Right now most of the alternatives to attachments require a fair amount of setup for the sender. Ours just requires they visit a page and upload the file.

Coming back to the issue of trust, that's definitely going to be a challenge for us as a company just starting out. If you have any ideas about how we can develop that trust I'd welcome them.

Thanks for the awesome feedback. :)