News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The $25B eigenvector (2006) [pdf] by mindcrime on Sunday January 07, 2018 @07:02PM (#16093608)
Ya know, I get what you're saying and I am somewhat sympathetic to this position. But I think you're being a bit harsh. It's easy to talk about "understand(ing) that this is an extremely important topic" when you already know. But how many high-school kids really know anything about Linear Algebra or understand much at all about how/where it's used? Heck, rewind time a bit and ask if you really understood that when you were first starting college. And if you did, realize that you are probably the exception.

From a university lecture in linear algebra, I expect that it carries me through as many important topics as possible while giving me the tools to form a good formal and intuitive understanding.

Sure and unless your goal is to do pure mathematics research, part of that is providing some motivation in terms of understanding applications. There's nothing wrong with a class on LA (or any other topic as far as that goes) spending some time motivating study of the topic by showing how it can be useful... even explaining how it might used to make millions or billions of dollars.

Re:The $25B eigenvector (2006) [pdf] by zitterbewegung on Sunday January 07, 2018 @08:43PM (#16094047)
When I took math in college there was no motivating examples for nearly everything. I had to complete my CS courses to understand nearly a quarter of the actual applications of what I learned in my math class. The only reason that I even know more applications right now is the fact that I am trying to teach myself SMT solving and ML. Why can't we have a math book that has motivating examples applicable to everyone? Or if that is too hard then just one for Computer Science?

Right now in nearly every Math book that is bought by a College student or High School student has motivations in Phyaics. So a person could go through HS, get their Undergraduate degree in CS and then never figure out how math could be useful in their job at all. When students ask "when am I going to use this" you have already failed in teaching your students how to apply this.

Once they have reached this point either they will have a really bad impression of math and just give up OR they will believe whatever you say after words and get rewarded ten years down the line.