Re:Convenient End-To-End Encryption for E-Mail
by tptacek on Sunday January 07, 2018 @06:19PM
(#16093344)
For the nth time on this thread: TLS does not provide end-to-end encryption for email. End-to-end encryption means you can read your mail, and the person who receives your email can read it, and no system in between can ever see the plaintext.
* Most mail transport agents can require connections to use TLS, but nobody does because they're afraid of denying incoming messages and because it can be difficult to install a certificate for an MTA, so smaller providers just don't. There should be a LetsEncrypt for mail servers and by default the various package managers and distributions should not install a mail agent that allows non-TLS connections.
* It is possible to store mail messages encrypted at rest, but only by using an encrypted filesystem-- I'm not aware of any MTA that will do this itself. Obviously that needs to change.
* Providers can force TLS connections for IMAP. This is surprisingly easier these days given that most end user mail clients will auto-negotiate these connections.
There's your E2E encryption. This doesn't get you encryption on the final destination, but that's a separate issue.