News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by tmsh on Monday August 16, 2010 @01:19PM (#1608409)
I expect to be downvoted as the signal that I would indicate is not exactly on the same wavelength as most -- and so you'll probably interpret it as noise.

However, I think Nicholas Carr's points are not completely without value. The problem is if you attach qualitative judgment to it (the changing mind is good / bad, etc.) -- because it's very difficult to judge those things without knowing the future. For instance, take this note from the post:

UPDATE. A reader reminded me that Socrates was worried about the impact of written arguments many centuries ago. People have been wailing about technology spoiling everything for a long time.

Arguably, this 'linear' way of thinking that he argues pre-Internet writing cultivated -- arguably, that has real limitations. If you've ever studied ancient Greek, you might've noticed how anti-linear the language is (because of variable word order, cases, tenses, particles, etc.). In many ways Greek was a much more powerful way of thinking. And in many ways it works better in an oral environment. There is perhaps a reason that the Iliad and the Odyssey were created as oral poetry. As with a lot of archaic lyric and choral poetry that later formed the basis for Greek drama. And similarly, Socratic argument is something like the antithesis of a 'linear' mind (or certainly it complicates it).

So one might argue that linearity was a major problem that prevented, in certain areas, more dynamic, Renaissance-like thought until other languages developed a sufficiently rich and malleable base. Elizabethan English is anything but linear. Shakespeare, the spark and/or a central figure of that, was not linear in the written sense. 'Would that he had blotted a thousand lines...' was the general consensus until people paid better attention to his antilinearity, arguably.

But I mention all of this because it's important to study how different languages and mediums affect how we think. It's unlikely that anyone will figure out the present way of thinking, definitively, during the present. But I admire Nicholas Carr for trying (if I don't admire his judgments).

Perhaps he gets it completely wrong. Perhaps the internet allows us to have a non-linear renaissance of discourse, etc. But being precisely wrong is often half the battle, at least among analytical understandings of how mediums work, etc.

Or take Hacker News. The fact that you can't edit something that you post after a certain amount of time in conjunction with comments being attached a numerical 'value' from up/downmodding -- could dramatically affect what types of things are discussed here. I can understand the rationale (what's said is said -- editing after the fact is potentially disingenuous). However, people in turn may be less willing to take argumentative risks because they fear being locked into a 'trial' of an idea. Maybe this is good (for signal/noise). Maybe this is bad (low discursive risks, low discursive rewards). And I'm sure there are many other factors. But arguably it's worth thinking about all the effects of any type of medium.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by jerf on Monday August 16, 2010 @02:23PM (#1608660)
If I were going to downmod you, it would be because you go on for rather a while about an ill-defined concept, backed by vague references to hundreds of years at a time as if they could somehow be meaningfully captured by such a quick sketch. How do we measure "linearity"? How do you address the fact that regardless of the language, human text and speech is a serialization of an arbitrarily interlinked concept? (And thank goodness I can fall back on programmer-jargon to ask that question, I'm so very glad I didn't have to type that in non-jargon.) What is linearity, exactly?

There very way may be sharp, clear answers you can give me that will shut me down, in which case I will graciously admit it. But I don't know what they may be.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by tmsh on Monday August 16, 2010 @02:49PM (#1608754)
I do speak in very, very general terms here.

But I think you can still extract valuable insights if you're careful and you qualify these abstractions. It could be useful to analyze what the nature of an HN signal is? Could be very-low on argumentative properties. And very high on objective, factual properties. This could be good. But it could be a mistake then to presume that this is a 'forum' in which discursive/argumentative qualities are usually a bit more flexibly welcomed, etc.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by jerf on Monday August 16, 2010 @02:51PM (#1608764)
"But I think you can still extract valuable insights if you're careful and you qualify these abstractions."

Err, yes, but were you planning on offering any such careful qualifications? I can't explain your ideas to you.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by tmsh on Monday August 16, 2010 @02:58PM (#1608788)
Ok. Linearity isn't my term -- it's jgc's. But I presume he and Carr mean something like a sustained engagement via a body of text. In essay writing, this usually involves multiple revisions, again and again, across the same space. In essay reading, this usually involves a closer level of engagement with a text and its progression than is otherwise normal -- somehow, via its thoroughness, it challenges us.

The disadvantages with this type of approach are that you can get off base. Hence, something more dynamic, with feedback (in the form of a Socratic dialogue, etc.) can be much more useful. Perhaps the Internet has the potential for being more Socratic -- was my point before. But only if we understand exactly how it fits -- how, arguably, we've been waiting for this, in our linearity, for a long time. But if we abuse its dynamic qualities, we might totally lose it. So Nick Carr by reminding us that we might think about these things -- is useful.

The advantages of the linear approach are that by dwelling with something in an engaged manner -- you can often extract value that otherwise superficial readings don't. At some point all ideas come into contact with each other, and are validated, etc. But arguably by giving people more space to develop their ideas -- sort of mentioned in this article:

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/16/technology/16brain.html

-- you extract more value.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by tygorius on Monday August 16, 2010 @03:32PM (#1608900)
Your thesis seems rather a reach to me. Socratic dialogues are a sequential form -- earlier points lay the groundwork for later ones, for example.

I'm not an expert on the ancient Greeks, but the last I heard there wasn't much evidence of a written language during the Greek Dark Ages. But to jump from what we know of Greek culture from written remnants (plays and poetry) it would seem to place a great deal of emphasis on "linearity".

Take the Method of Loci used to, ahem, memorize the "linear" points of a speech or argument. While it's true that you can access points at random, that doesn't take away from the fact that they are staged and memorized in a specific order for presentation.

Bottom line, I think you're accepting the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis uncritically. It seems so reasonable, but when you get down to specifics -- like the actual number of words for snow in English and Innuit -- it just doesn't pan out. Similarly, I think anyone who's read Adler and Van Doren's pre-Internet "How to Read a Book" would scoff at Carr's notion that books can't be an interactive medium. People can be mentally lazy using any media.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by tmsh on Monday August 16, 2010 @05:03PM (#1609251)
The Method of Loci sounds very interesting (as well as the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis).

But if we're still presuming that speech is inherently linear, I think we're mistaking how the brain abstracts those sequences of texts. I haven't read the literature at all really, but I read On Intelligence (Jeff Hawkins), and my sense was that this lexing pass that happens when we greet language is happening very much in isolation before we start adding semantic meaning with 'hierarchies' or tree structures, etc. So the 'give off' from that linear feeding of word after word is pretty minimal.

Imho, the Method of Loci would apply greatly to how Greek language and literature works. There is a lot more investment of ideas into spatially separate, almost physical objects (Love is very much a physical god, etc.). This perhaps has the advantage of engaging the participant with those ideas more -- by activating the methods we use in our spatial reasoning. Similarly, in language, the flexibility of the word order really requires that you stack words in different locations, flexibly.

We read the Socratic dialogues linearly -- and Socrates leads us on what seems like a preordained line. But really there are lots of stacks and queues involved. It's a pretty dynamic process of finally finding a linear coherent structure that we're comfortable with. So in my mind it's still very dynamic.

But you make interesting points... Perhaps the best way to evoke the most information with language is to be aware of the distinction between the sequential and dynamic -- and to maximize the good parts of both. They're really yin and yang with each other -- great essay writing is a linear product, made of dynamic error-checking at each step, etc.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by cdr on Monday August 16, 2010 @01:25PM (#1608437)
Leading with "I expect to be downvoted" is the surest way to get me to downvote you.
Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by tmsh on Monday August 16, 2010 @02:44PM (#1608744)
I suppose my point was to challenge your signal-sensing apparatus. The problem of putting signal v. noise on a pedestal is that we take for granted what the shape of good signals looks like.
Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by Retric on Monday August 16, 2010 @04:02PM (#1609007)
Signal is easy to game, simply be direct and to the point.

PS: Think of all the words I could have used to say the same thing.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by tmsh on Monday August 16, 2010 @04:37PM (#1609137)
Again, this would be a valid criticism if I had simply said:

'I expect to be downvoted.'

Or if I were trying to game the system or otherwise accumulate points. As odd as it is to imagine though, that's not actually my point. My point, to be direct, is that:

I expect to be downvoted as the signal that I would indicate is not exactly on the same wavelength as most -- and so you'll probably interpret it as noise.

Though I don't mean to be argumentative (esp. by repeating myself). But I mean you raise a good point. However, it's not like I just signed up for HN yesterday. I've been reading this for a year or so, and I recognize what will be downvoted. Maybe I'm doing it on purpose though? Maybe I want you to downvote me and then think about it? What I often get after -- and am always downvoted for -- is that there are large differences within this category of 'trolling', which we assume everyone who isn't being immediately, objectively informative is a part of. There are unhelpful trolls, for sure. But there are also helpful trolls. You could even go so far as to say: people like Socrates -- who arguably contribute more to the difficult, valuable, formative stages of things like science than anyone else. I'm just trying to remind people to not get too complacent about what a good signal looks like.

Re:Is The Times making you stupid? by Retric on Monday August 16, 2010 @07:11PM (#1609625)
You misunderstood me. You have a bad habit of using a lot of words to say vary little little. EX: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1598977

PS: Your comment can easily be read as: to be argumentative I'm doing /this/ on purpose. I believe there are helpful trolls /and I am trying to be one./ It's sitting at the noise floor, so why spend the time looking for a deeper meaning?

Note: The above actually said vary little wasted a lot of words and is intended as an example of what no to do while using vaguely insulting weasel words for the fun of it (can easily be read as etc).