Re:Germany vs. Elsevier: universities win temporary free jou...
by revelation on Friday January 05, 2018 @01:17PM
(#16080399)
They "edit" them in the sense that they pay an Indian outsourcing company to fuck up your formatting, then send you a list of typos that aren't.
Re:Germany vs. Elsevier: universities win temporary free jou...
by jhbadger on Friday January 05, 2018 @04:41PM
(#16081944)
It varies a lot by field. I'm a computational biologist and have dealt with both the CS and biology ways of doing things. In CS you send a formatted LaTeX manuscript to the publisher and they basically just print that, but the traditional biology way is just to send a Word document with little formatting at all. It is considered the job of the publisher to turn the Word document into something that actually is formatted.
Re:Germany vs. Elsevier: universities win temporary free jou...
by delib on Friday January 05, 2018 @01:34PM
(#16080522)
Right (although this depends on the journal). But these problems are a function of Elsevier's immense market power as well.
Re:Germany vs. Elsevier: universities win temporary free jou...
by FabHK on Friday January 05, 2018 @06:05PM
(#16082572)
> Elsevier does provide a service.
Mediocre service, as you say yourself. Furthermore, they earn way above market returns on equity. It's really not a competitive enterprise, but extracting rent (from the tax payer via university library budgets).
* Edit: Of course, they don't do it in a particularly good way.