News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by turblety on Friday January 05, 2018 @06:22AM (#16077949)
I think this will be good in the long run. If VISA (and Mastercard) end up allowing Bitcoin affiliated payments through their platform, then merchants will end up not providing native support for crypto payments, as they can just use their current infrastructure.

If we want to destroy these payment monopolies in place of a (more, but I understand not completely) decentralized system, we need to encourage merchants to just implement payments directly.

edit: typical hackernews. any pro bitcoin comments result in downvotes.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by raverbashing on Friday January 05, 2018 @06:50AM (#16078051)
You can't have it both ways

I'm sure a lot of people said "this is good for bitcoin" when they launched this

Looking forward to read how having long confirmation times, high fees and high volatility is good for bitcoin

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by ThomPete on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:54AM (#16078528)
From what I understand one seriously thinks about bitcoin as a currency anymore.

Think of it as gold for the digital space almost literally (it's expensive to mine, exist in limited quantity and expensive to keep secure)

People keep talking about high volatility but any currency can be exposed to high volatility and there was a time when currency was that. Now we have central banks but they have their own problems with systemtic bubbles.

Bitcoin will be a kind of contract ledger perhaps between countries or large organizations.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by joosters on Friday January 05, 2018 @06:29AM (#16077979)
Ah, another classic "This is good for Bitcoin"
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by repomies691 on Friday January 05, 2018 @06:47AM (#16078035)
I didn't see it that way, more like advocating the development of some kind of open, permissionless payment network. Bitcoin could be it but it has ridiculous network fees, which opens the possibilities for challengers. If everything works very fluently with the traditional payment infrastructure, there is no big demand for that kind of payment network, and no incentives to develop it.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by bringtheaction on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:22AM (#16078161)
The challengers are here already.

For example, XRB.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by zepolen on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:19AM (#16078353)
Wow I tried it and you're right RaiBlocks is a game changer. Instant transaction and zero fee? Hows the security though?
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by blueprint on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:03AM (#16078587)
Can you make the fact you're a shill any more obvious?
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by zepolen on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:35PM (#16083023)
Are you kidding, last time I played with crypto the confirmations took like an hour - I didn't really bother using it any more.

I don't know how XRB makes it so fast but I'm calling it right now - whoever has the fastest transaction speed will become the first global currency.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by blueprint on Friday January 05, 2018 @10:25PM (#16083666)
Have fun with PayPal and Visa then. Some people just don't get it.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by kaybe on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:12AM (#16078639)
Is it possible to have something that does not use obscene amounts of electricity? Or would that be captured immediately by someone who can use more ressources = electricity?
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by oelmekki on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:02AM (#16078096)
I don't see this happening for bitcoin, though (or maybe for online orders, which don't need to be instant).

Two years ago, I got sick of banks whose services I found of lesser and lesser quality, and tried a bitcoin/VISA debit card, just to see if it was working. The idea was this: I make a bitcoin transaction to add bitcoins in card provider wallet, and when transaction is complete, I could exchange it for fiat that I could use with my card.

"when transaction is complete" is the culprint :) I needed to have fiat in the card so that payments to a cashier was instant. If you remove that step, transaction delays make it not realistic for buying stuff while outdoor, especially given current delays (but even two years ago, it wouldn't do).

So, for bitcoin to work without VISA (or alike) as third party, bitcoin will first need to find a way to make transactions instant.

The alternative, obviously, being to use it for purchases where transaction delay doesn't matter (like online purchases), or to use an other cryptocurrency for that.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by repomies691 on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:05AM (#16078114)
For online payments instant payments are actually not that important requirements. The process needs to happen just fluently from customers perspective. If the merchant is dispatching physical items, he can just wait for the transaction to confirm and dispatch the items after that. The customer won't see much difference because the biggest issue is the shipping time.

For online payments bitcoin works quite well. Still credit cards are often better for the consumer, because of the consumer protection (chargebacks).

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by doktrin on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:30AM (#16078186)
> For online payments bitcoin works quite well

Bitcoin payments could, theoretically, work well - but that's not currently the case given the prohibitive transaction fees.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by oelmekki on Friday January 05, 2018 @08:14AM (#16078330)
Indeed, didn't think about it, but fees are a problem as well. Also, if bitcoin had to manage the throughput of VISA (or even a fraction of it, at this point), capacity issues would probably worsen dramatically.

It's probably best to stop hoping it will be a currency altogether (unless some radical changes occur). Best shot would be to see it as saving/investment accounts, with smart tricks like prepaid visa cards as a mean to tap into it (I want to buy a car, I charge my prepaid card and pay with it at car dealer, fast transfer compared to a wire transfer, no "weekly withdraw limit" issue and still as convenient as a debit card).

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by etr-strike on Friday January 05, 2018 @10:06AM (#16078980)
Lightning Network exceeds the throughput of VISA. The scaling problem is being addressed -- just not in the naive "let's throw away decentralization and increase the blocksize" way.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by oelmekki on Friday January 05, 2018 @10:40AM (#16079246)
I've heard mentions about the lightning network quite a lot in previous years, but never got what the implementation was. I get it it's "offchain transactions", but how does it relate to bitcoin, exactly? Is it "sidechains", like lisk (each third party managing its own blockchain), or is it simply "outsourcing" money and transactions and waiting for a general report from the trusted party to engrave it in the blockchain?
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by Nursie on Friday January 05, 2018 @01:32PM (#16080507)
It seems to work by setting up channels of funds between entities. To create a channel and fund it requires a bitcoin transaction. Payments from the fund to the recipient can then proceed off-chain to a maximum of the fund amount, then another on-chain transaction settles it.

This sounds somewhat cumbersome, but AFAICT the gains apparently come from routing between channels, so if A wants to pay B, and channels exist from A->C and C->B then payments can route that way, without the need for more on-chain transactions.

To me this sounds really quite complex, and also like it's going to involve intermediary 'hubs' which will process off-chain transactions and... well it sounds like banks and centralisation again, something the BTC crowd apparently hate.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by oelmekki on Friday January 05, 2018 @02:10PM (#16080790)
I see, thanks for the explanation. As is, it kind of seems to defeat the idea of the blockchain, dropping it to do a meaningful amount of transactions. But it's well over my head, I'll wait and see how it plays out.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by vkou on Friday January 05, 2018 @01:57PM (#16080687)
> For online payments instant payments are actually not that important requirements.

When the exchange rate fluctuates as much as it does, instant payment is an important requirement.

Suppose BTC is worth $15,000 today. I want to buy a widget for $150.

I want to see 0.01 BTC deducted from my balance. The merchant wants to get paid $150.

If the transaction happens instantly, everyone is happy.

If the transaction does not happen instantly...

Let's say I transact 0.01 BTC to the payment processor. It will clear tomorrow. The merchant will get paid when it clears. Tomorrow... The payment processor has 0.01 BTC in their possession.

... Except that by then, BTC went down to $13,000. The merchant still expects to be paid $150. The payment processor has 0.01 BTC on their books, which is worth $130... and a debt of $150.

That's the problem with using BTC as a currency. You either need to pay through the nose for fast confirmation, or you expose yourself to volatility risk.

This is, incidentally, why Steam has stopped accepting Bitcoin. You can't use it as a currency. [1]

[1] http://steamcommunity.com/games/593110/announcements/detail/...

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by dagw on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:36AM (#16078198)
For online payments bitcoin works quite well

Many people who tried to buy stuff on Steam with bitcoin seem to disagree. In fact Steam recently stopped accepting bitcoin since they apparently couldn't make it work.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by jpindar on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:40AM (#16078806)
I assume you mean recently. I used bitcoin on Steam a few years ago and it worked fine.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by Nursie on Friday January 05, 2018 @02:13PM (#16080822)
It's quite recent and I presume because of fees, delays and volatility.

Dell stopped accepting it too. Ironically the rocketing speculative value is killing the prospects for longer term use and stability.

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by etr-strike on Friday January 05, 2018 @10:06AM (#16078986)
As they should -- Lightning Network is the correct technological solution for small frequent payments such as game purchases on Steam.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by oelmekki on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:07AM (#16078119)
Which is why I mentioned the distinction :)
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by empath75 on Friday January 05, 2018 @06:47AM (#16078038)
I can’t wait to wait 3 days and spend $30 in transaction fees to buy a Big Mac.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by pmorici on Friday January 05, 2018 @09:52AM (#16078884)
Bitcoin Cash fixes that.
Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by s3nnyy on Friday January 05, 2018 @07:49AM (#16078241)
Right now I top up 10USD worth of Bitcoin with bitrefill.com.

I pay ZERO fees and it is instant (due to Segwit and the Lightning network).

Re:Bitcoin Visa debit cards are cancelled by s3nnyy on Saturday January 06, 2018 @10:15AM (#16085584)
Why the negative reaction to this?