It's not that there are never security issues on non-cloud systems, but the risk of cloud is severely underappreciated. I don't know how anyone can claim otherwise in a post-Specre world. At least on non-cloud, you don't have to worry about the CPU stabbing you in the back.
Spectre can read data out of memory at hundreds of kilobytes per second. That's plenty fast to get interesting data out of Coinbase even if they're "rapidly cycling" their instances. And really that just means you just have to camp out and wait for them to come to you, rather than trying really hard to get on the same instance as them, which would probably be harder. You just have to know what region + az they're in (not secret), and you can probably guesstimate some other stuff and end up on a similar hardware class, and then I am sure that after not-too-long they'll join your host.
And sure, Spectre is now "mitigated" as far as we know, but it wasn't until recently, so we don't know who could've done this, and it's not like that's the only VM isolation breaker out there. There are certainly more conventional bugs that are readily exploited. There are also other non-technical attack vectors on a provider like AWS, like Amazon employees.
I may be more understanding if there was some important reason to take these kinds of risks, but honestly it's ridiculous that people cling to the cloud so desperately. Hardware is not that scary and a lot of hardware jockeys are pretty friendly. Is software really so age-discriminatory that no one remembers a life before cloud servers? It wasn't that bad!
Call your local hardware vendor and they'd be ecstatic to set you up with a rack running VMWare or Xen or whatever "private cloud", giving you the convenience of a hypervisor without the risk profile of sharing a CPU with every Tom Dick or Harry on the internet.
And the real kicker? It'll be 10x cheaper than the annual AWS bill for comparable resources.
Noone has been running their own datacenter for a while.
I tend to agree that new businesses are very unlikely to invest in their own metal - because it's not really a path to profitability, but many small-medium businesses run their own data centers. Especially if the business was founded in the 90s and the leadership hasn't chosen to invest in tech.
Many businesses choose not to scale (in ways which cloud services would help) - many more just have no need to scale (i.e. regional service providers).
Try outsourcing a software project to some sweatshops, they will offer you to rent the hardware in their datacenters. Germany is no exception.
Now more than ever, this statement just does not compute. What good reason could something as sensitive as Coinbase have to remain on a third-party cloud provider and let Amazon hold the keys to the kingdom, especially after this disclosure that informs us that our imagined VM sandboxes have been a fairy tale all along?
There's a secret from a time not so long past that makes these attacks nearly-irrelevant: "don't run untrusted code". Maybe the corollary "don't run on hardware that runs untrusted code" is necessary (though I personally feel it's a little redundant).
It's embarrassing that Coinbase would continue to expose their application to this attack surface after yesterday's disclosures. Honestly, it should've been that way before; this isn't the first time VM isolation has been broken, and it won't be the last. It's just the least-fixable breakage so far.
> Sensitive workloads, especially where key handling is involved, run on Dedicated Instances (instead of shared hardware). Where we do run on shared hardware, we make it more difficult to accurately target one of our systems by rapidly cycling through instances in AWS.
I'm quoting this just because I know people will say I'm excluding the context if I don't. If you're going to run on "dedicated instances" anyway and pay the huge price premium for them, there's no reason to continue to put your secrets in Amazon's hands.
Little ragtag startups may use the excuse "We're scared of real sysadmins, they will laugh at us because they're over 25", but that excuse should not work for something as big and serious as Coinbase.
Playing Instance Roulette by "rapid cycling [instances]" in hopes that you get away from any bad neighbors ASAP is extremely silly, please give me a break. Just buy some hardware. How is this so hard?