News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by alecco on Monday August 16, 2010 @08:47AM (#1607603)
I'm a complete outsider of the subject, but with complex licensing and trivial software patents there's often something overlooked, some clause. One of the comments there mentions incompatibilities in classlibs.
Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by protomyth on Monday August 16, 2010 @10:53AM (#1607918)
Well, buying a license that doesn't actually fully cover what you are buying would tend to not make sense.

Oracle going after IBM and its huge patent portfolio has about the same chances as a gerbil attacking a tiger. Theoretically possible, but not a good idea.

Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by Pahalial on Monday August 16, 2010 @12:33PM (#1608270)
Eminently true. Even with the acquisition of Sun's portfolio, Oracle is still dwarfed by Big Blue several times over.

Suffice it to say, IBM has had the most patents granted of any American company for the past 17 consecutive years as of early 2010: http://www.networkworld.com/news/2010/011210-patents-2009.ht...

Certainly an unknown quantity must be quite specious, but the sheer cost of fighting the number of patents they could counter-attack with would probably bankrupt Oracle, not to mention however many turned out to have merit.

Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by jimbokun on Monday August 16, 2010 @02:42PM (#1608734)
"a gerbil attacking a tiger"

Very apt description of the SCO vs. IBM law suit, with the predictable result.

Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by alecco on Monday August 16, 2010 @05:43PM (#1609388)
You are reflecting on hindsight. Also, SCO didn't happen to own Unix. That was why they lost, IBM's size didn't affect the outcome as much as the particular details. Oracle owns rightfully Java and all its related patents.

AFAIK, Oracle can pull a low blow like not licensing Java to IBM next time or perhaps more subtle putting ridiculous clauses for new standardized versions. They can even do so with popular support by switching to Affero GPLv3, for example. IBM would never run something like that license due to the patent-related characteristics of it.

I wouldn't underestimate Oracle.

Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by protomyth on Monday August 16, 2010 @05:56PM (#1609436)
It isn't the corporate size that is the issue, it is the size of the patent portfolio that IBM has. I would not doubt IBM's response to any of your scenarios is to find 10 or so patents key to Oracle's database software and file a patent infringement case.

I don't think we are underestimating Oracle, we are just given IBM their due.

Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by alecco on Monday August 16, 2010 @06:17PM (#1609489)

  >>> "a gerbil attacking a tiger"
  > It isn't the corporate size that is the issue
Argh.

And note I originally gave IBM as an example of just ONE possible target after Google. So you selectively challenge one point and then even on that point dismiss the other issues (like the "low blow" argument where Oracle doesn't even have to sue the target, be it IBM or some other deep pocketed corporation.)

Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by protomyth on Tuesday August 17, 2010 @10:25AM (#1611191)
I admit to a bit of confusion on your response. I was pointing out in the "low blow" scenario that Oracle is much more vulnerable than IBM to a contest of patents. Oracle might not be suing in your scenarios, but that wouldn't stop a suit by IBM.

The crux of this whole thing is that Google isn't using the GPLed version, wasn't paying a license fee to Sun, and isn't to Oracle. Oracle believes Google should and (probably after failed talks) is filing a lawsuit. IBM and Blackberry payed to license like other companies. So, Oracle really has no reason to sue anyone but Google.