What I meant was that the presence of the bug itself is not a valid cause, for example you can't claim that due to the error you lost 1 trillion dollars via a software hack - even if it's true. If Intel can prove they acted ethically when disclosing the bug and that they replaced / compensated users up to the value of the CPU, they are in the clear.
Yes and no. Yes, Intel would get a chance to claim that the case should be dismissed out of hand. To do that, they have to prove that, even assuming all the claimed facts are true, the people suing still don't have a valid case. That's a high bar. It can be reached - there's a reason that preliminary summary judgment is a thing in court cases - but it takes a really flawed case to be dismissed in this way.
How flawed? SCO v. IBM was not completely dismissed on preliminary summary judgment, and that was the most flawed case I've ever seen.
> It may very well be a question of who has the better legal team.
Well, Intel can afford to hire the best. A huge class-action suit can sometimes attract the best to the other side as well, though. (There's not just one "best", so there's enough for both sides of the same court case.)
IANAL, but it looks to me like there's at least the potential for a valid court case. CPUs are (approximately) priced according to their ability to handle workloads; if they can't provide the advertised performance, they didn't deserve the price they sold for.
The question is did anyone receive performance assurance from Intel? Probably not.
Some cloud providers or compute grids just lost a lot. Maybe they will find an angle to claim compensation.
If people who received written assurance from Intel that their hardware is 100% bug free can form a legal class, sure. I highly doubt there is even a single one such customer.