Re:Genetic Study Supports Carbohydrate-Insulin Model of Obesity
by spion on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:50AM
(#16061945)
Hi ericschmidt, your comment is dead for some reason, so I'll reply here
I like Jason Fung's theory best too, but there still are some problems. Its true that I've mischaracterised it somewhat, but he seems to hold several theories at once, for example:
The desensitisation theory (eating too many carbs too often without pause we desensitise our insulin receptors, causing increased insulin secretion) has the same problem as the lock-and-key/fat model - how come the liver receptors are still just as sensitive to insulin when it comes to producing fat? There is some inconsistency there, for sure - its either my lack of familiarity with the topic, or a problem with the theory.
I like Jason Fung's theory best too, but there still are some problems. Its true that I've mischaracterised it somewhat, but he seems to hold several theories at once, for example:
* The overflow theory: https://www.dietdoctor.com/new-paradigm-insulin-resistance
* The insulin desensitisation theory: https://www.dietdoctor.com/insulin-causes-insulin-resistance
The desensitisation theory (eating too many carbs too often without pause we desensitise our insulin receptors, causing increased insulin secretion) has the same problem as the lock-and-key/fat model - how come the liver receptors are still just as sensitive to insulin when it comes to producing fat? There is some inconsistency there, for sure - its either my lack of familiarity with the topic, or a problem with the theory.