News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2018 Is the Last Year of America's Public Domain Drought by sytelus on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @08:33AM (#16051726)
Let me just turn the table around. Why should intellectual property copyright not last in perpetuity? A core proposition in Western world is that intellectual property is indistinguishable from other properties such as house you own or piece of art you create or your stamp collection or your startups. When you die, you have right to transfer these properties to your designated heir. Your properties does not become a public properties when you die even when it would have been good for the society. Why intellectual property should have vastly different treatment?

BTW, I am absolutely not advocating that current definition of intellectual properties is correct or even fair. I am just saying that assuming if this definition was ideal, wouldn't above make sense?

Re:2018 Is the Last Year of America's Public Domain Drought by Jedd on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @08:40AM (#16051754)
> A core proposition in Western world is that intellectual property is indistinguishable from other properties such as house you own or piece of art you create or your stamp collection or your startups.

It really is not.

What makes you believe that it is?

> When you die, you have right to transfer these properties to your designated heir.

A great many people who don't get to inherit their wealth have been questioning this mantra for centuries, probably longer (albeit more cautiously).

Re:2018 Is the Last Year of America's Public Domain Drought by eukgoekoko on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @09:27AM (#16051974)
I bet the Chinese as the inventors of paper would be happy to get some royalties from the Western world.
Re:2018 Is the Last Year of America's Public Domain Drought by swsieber on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @09:31AM (#16051998)
Media companies have cast IP as such, but it really didn't start that way. IP started as a way to encourage creation, and it acknowledged as artificial.