It's not arbitrary however.
Here are some essentially inviolate principles of good design: http://graphicdesign.spokanefalls.edu/tutorials/process/gest...
For example, there's no reason why search boxes should have rounded corners - it's just an arbitrary style. But since users are familiar with rounded search boxes, using them could make your site easier to use.
That somewhat explains the trends you see in design, because when we employ a convergent design standard, it's more readily accessible in a single visit than a design that breaks away from current conventions.
It's also empirically the case that the convergent design standards represent the 'fittest'.
And I would argue that evolutionary speaking they represent 'good design' (that's my definition anyway).
The folks who designed those old amber IBM terminals (that I still use at work) would have argued that:
- Black background is easy on the eyes.
- The flashing cursor draws your focus.
- The amazing bold font technology breaks up the page very nicely.
So it would appear that "good design" is just a function of the technology available.