* Valve didn't shut the discussion down altogether. If the GitHub page wasn't the right place, then suggesting a forum where feedback would be appropriate and actually prompt a response would be the way to go. * Valve (or rather, their support staff) didn't have a history of extolling the perfection of VAC while dealing with some false bans in private. * Bans didn't have such large implications, or: * The support and appeal process wasn't so obtuse, seemingly useless and blackboxed.
I think they'd be encouraged to take more chances with their Anti-cheat ideas if the process for fixing false positives wasn't so genetically corporate and so user-hostile.
This is absolute bullshit and like saying "issue of rape in prison was raised by criminals who are evil so it's a feature for society they get raped".
And here's a money quote (guess whose):
> When the truth of one issue goes against a person's political leanings, that person will generally say whatever they can to avoid feeling guilt or shame.
If you look at the history, you will find that there were a handful of ban waves that were reverted or adjusted after they were found to be false positives.
It seems that the discussion was opened and driven by the developers and users of the bot. Not expecting too much for them.
Kisak, a Valve Employee, confirms that VAC bans are being handed out for usernames matching catbot. Yes, it was open and driven by the people that were banned because of a username.
Instead, Kisak's exact words were:
> Good day, I've received word from the VAC team that this is intentional and not open for discussion on Github.
In context of the cheaters and their sockpuppets, "this" probably refers to Valve going after the catbot malware makers and not banning based on one username specifically.
In all likelihood, VAC's detection is premised on other factors in combination with the username. Like, for example, botting in online multiplayer games.
This may come as a surprise to half the users in these comments, but, for the 99% of gamers who are not malware enthusiasts, banning bad actors is a feature, not a bug.