Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s...
by jjeaff on Monday January 01, 2018 @03:34PM
(#16047885)
I just don't see Alexa making huge inroads for shipping. It will be/is great for recurring purchases of stuff you already buy on Amazon, but people were already going directly to Amazon for that.
But using a voice system to buy new stuff just isn't a good experience. It's like the old days of catalog shopping with a phone except there's no catalog.
People need to pull up and see, look at reviews, watch YouTube review videos. Audio only just doesn't do that and is a step backwards.
I don't even use Alexa for reorders because I want to make sure I'm still getting a good deal everytime I order. And for those that don't care about the deal, they can just setup subscription purchasing.
Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s...
by Eridrus on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @10:18AM
(#16052275)
Some people need that, sure. I think Amazon may have a trust problem, but I've brought products based entirely on the Wirecutter/sweethome reviews, and I can easily imagine talking to their bot about what microwave they recommend. None of this works well now, but if Amazon builds a hardware moat, Google may not have a chance to compete with better software.
But if there are technological shifts that invalidate the investment Google has made, then there is a chance.
I think you're spot on about why Google is investing in the Assistant, but I think you underestimate the threat from Alexa. If Alexa gets a foot hold and manages to use the fact that you're having a dialog to deliver commercial queries better, Google is in a lot of trouble.
Vertical-specific commerce sites are also a threat, if you no longer search Google for insurance, but go directly to an insurance aggregator, Google's search tech is irrelevant to capturing that advertising revenue. I think Craigslist is undergoing this problem since they've basically refused to invest in better UX, vertical specific sites are eating their lunch.