News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by yters on Thursday April 10, 2008 @07:34PM (#160467)
In a purely technical sense, none of the web 2.0 phenomena is special. What are blogs, social networks, and the like? Merely the web pages that we nerds have been messing with since the dawn of the internet.

However, the real "technology" is how the popular perception of this tech has been (purposefully?) changed so it is no longer "techie."

On the other hand, the fundamental problems of the internet are not inherently technological anyways, but based on social dynamics and trust. That is why things like facebook and myspace are important.

What I would like to see some genius do is figure out what the "purpose" of the internet is. By this, I mean what is the compelling, concrete, and feasible potential of the internet? Sounds like a facile question, but it isn't. I don't mean something like "communicate faster, broadly, and more efficiently" or "watch porn."

There is a deep, underlying motivation that compels us to interact and be social, to avoid loneliness and the like, despite all the narcissistic toys we surround ourselves with. Why, and what does the internet do for this motivation?

Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by xlnt on Thursday April 10, 2008 @07:40PM (#160476)
facebook makes no interesting steps forward in solving trust problems. i made an account. people give facebook their email password and thus entire address book (this amuses me when the topic is setting up reasonable trust system), and thus i sometimes get friend requests from acquaintances. which i ignore.

all they came up with is letting you make one type of connection with other people with an account. nothing to see here. the only thing that makes it notable is the large amount of data put into it.

Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by yters on Thursday April 10, 2008 @07:57PM (#160499)
Yes, I think facebook started out right, but now the pressure to profit is causing them to make stupid decisions.

The key is to allow the kind of control people have in real relationships. From what I understand, it isn't possible to terminate facebook friendships, and that eliminates the basis of accountability needed for a good trust relationship.