News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by walterbell on Monday January 01, 2018 @01:37AM (#16045012)
What are some business models that could support a user-oriented search interface? Probably not advertising, if (big if) the new approach will return better search results than Google. Subscriptions have only worked for a few well-known services with exclusive content.

Would users be willing to learn a more powerful interface, if they consider current search engine results “good enough”?

Could Wikipedia or Archive.org address a subset of the search market, since they offer user-focused services? Archive.org already crawls a subset of the web.

Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by Nuzzerino on Monday January 01, 2018 @02:33AM (#16045139)
There are probably many that I haven't thought of. It may be possible that it is next to impossible to create both a better experience for the users, and create more revenue for the company at the same time.

It doesn't need to have a huge amount of users, it doesn't need to get the majority of the market share, and it doesn't need to earn more revenue, or even any revenue at all, in order to deliver a better user experience. Such things are not mutually exclusive.

I believe this is most likely to happen with the help of peer to peer technologies, combined with a healthy synergistic ecosystem of content curators, content providers, and content consumers. Steemit is a crude proof of concept for such a system. In Steemit, comments and posts are scored with a reputation algorithm, and assigned a tag. There's absolutely no reason why web links can't be associated with an arbitrary number of contextually-weighted tags, and a contextual reputation algorithm.

Everything that Google does could be done in a peer to peer manner, with each user bearing a small piece of the responsibility. Wikipedia is a great example of this, with many users contributing to the system. No single company could ever produce the amount of content that the Wikipedia userbase has created. Even though Wikipedia uses a centralized foundation and centralized server, the editing culture itself is decentralized, with a set of principles being the main driver of decision-making.

I bring up blockchain technologies, much to the disgust of many users on HN, but only because I see those technologies as lowering the barrier to creating systems such as Wikipedia, through automating, standardization, and enforcement of some of the mechanisms. It also creates a guarantee that a central authority doesn't exist and therefore cannot be manipulated in subtle ways by those in positions of greater power - That is a big appeal factor for a significant number of users, even if it is not the majority.

Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by user5994461 on Monday January 01, 2018 @03:04AM (#16045203)
>>> There are probably many that I haven't thought of. It may be possible that it is next to impossible to create both a better experience for the users, and create more revenue for the company at the same time.

Yes. Google cannot be beaten.

I don't think that any domain has more money to offer than advertising/marketing and certainly not easier. Then the real time auction and pricing systems that run Google are truly incredible.

Business wise, google is milking the perfect cow perfectly. There isn't a better cow or a better milking strategy.

Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by ProxCoques on Monday January 01, 2018 @03:02AM (#16045193)
There has been at last one attempt at some of that:

http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/new...

I think it folded after a year.

Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by ybrah on Monday January 01, 2018 @01:42AM (#16045017)
Most people want the accessibility achieved through quick searches on their phones. The only users that would use a more powerful interface would be professionals. The professionals that would use it would be researchers, developers, and health practitioners.
Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by Nuzzerino on Monday January 01, 2018 @03:49AM (#16045311)
There's no reason that a powerful interface can't have an arbitrarily-designed, simple interface built on top of it. That's how computer systems generally work.
Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by walterbell on Monday January 01, 2018 @01:49AM (#16045031)
I wonder what those professionals use today: google’s advanced search interface, niche site search, social media search, libraries, paid services, bloomberg, lexis-nexis ..?
Re:Not only is it possible to beat Google, it could happen s... by ohtwenty on Monday January 01, 2018 @10:44AM (#16046451)
As far as I'm aware, in the Netherlands wrt health: specialised sites. Google is all WebMD or unverifiable claims, or just doesn't go in depth. So you check your UpToDate, or pubmed, your country's/specialization's current guidelines, farmacotherapeutisch kompas for medicine (https://www.farmacotherapeutischkompas.nl/ - search for medicine and find dosage, interactions, etc). Google is often good enough for a reminder, but won't hold up for specific knowledge or minute details. So at most that Google the name of the service to search on there. Which is why I use ddg - if I know what website/information store I'm going to end up going to, I might as well use the !bang to go there directly. And you know which tools to look at because you're given them when you're studying.