News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethereum Foundation Releases Alpha Casper Proof of Stake ... by konschubert on Sunday December 31, 2017 @08:15PM (#16044040)
No, the cost is NOT a necessary requirement for creating a secure network. Capital/stake is.

What you say is true for Proof-of-work: The more capital-intensive mining is, the harder the network is to attack.

One can say that PoW currencies are secured by a display of capital investment into mining. The stake is the electricity and hardware deprecation that goes into mining a block. Cost is used as a proxy for capital.

Proof-of-work takes the middle men out of this: You proof your capital investment (your stake) directly within the protocol.

Re:Ethereum Foundation Releases Alpha Casper Proof of Stake ... by magnetic on Monday January 01, 2018 @11:37AM (#16046685)
> What you say is true for Proof-of-work: The more capital-intensive mining is, the harder the network is to attack.

Well I did say "It takes a certain amount of money $X to control 51% of a POW network." Not sure why there is an argument around PoS.

Did you mean PoS in your last sentence?

It isn't clear to me that PoS is much different, in the sense that you can imagine attacking the network by gaining a larger stake, enough to be "calling the shots on the truth" (ie silencing other stakeholders). There are other comments along these lines so I won't repeat the arguments here.

Re:Ethereum Foundation Releases Alpha Casper Proof of Stake ... by konschubert on Monday January 01, 2018 @04:01PM (#16048021)
> Did you mean PoS in your last sentence?

Totally. Apoligies.

> It isn't clear to me that PoS is much different, in the sense that you can imagine attacking the network by gaining a larger stake, enough to be "calling the shots on the truth" (ie silencing other stakeholders).

I think we agree on this one: Proof of Stake and Proof of Work are both vulnerable to their respective 51% attacks.

But they are also (more or less) equally safe: If you don't have 51% of capital at stake/mining power, you cannot attack the network.

So, all things being equal, my argument is that PoS is advantagous because it requires fewer resources.

(This is expressed for example in the fact that the block reward with PoW needs to be much higher than with PoS to re-finance the same amount of capital investment. Because if proof of stake, you also get back your original capital.)