2. There is no recourse for those who have been banned or penalized.
3. I have tried to go through the normal channels and ask for an explanation.
4. I've been a member here for a decade, and typically that means something. Not a lot, but a little bit.
Part of HN's strength is its fastidiousness to these rules. But it's also a weakness. Isn't it convenient that the perfectly crafted ruleset just so happens to exclude any possibility of critiquing HN or asking "Hey, I'm in a situation that sucks, what should I do about this?"
So yes, feel free to simply not empathize. That's your right. And it's my right to continue causing trouble and escalating the situation until I get myself banned as a protest to overreaching moderation policies. I would rather go out fighting than be kicked repeatedly until I just get tired and quit.
(And whatever you say, you try writing HN comments when all of them immediately get whisked to the bottom and tell me it doesn't feel like a small kick each time it happens. Especially if you put effort into your writing, or care at all about quality.)
You do have recourse (email the mods), which you've used, and abused, both in quality and quantity by your own admission.
You've acknowledged that you've behaved in ways that are against the guidelines, and have ignored the feedback you've gotten and continued to post in ways that are against the guidelines.
You seem to be aware of these things yet apparently haven't taken them to heart or believe that they really don't apply to you. You've event acknowledged that if you continue behaving the way you are that you'll eventually get banned. Is that what you want to happen?
Posting on HN is not a right: it's a privilege.
Yet you can still potentially redeem yourself.
- Don't just post everything that comes to mind. You mention a few times in this thread that you spend time on your comments: spend more time, reviewing especially keeping in mind the feedback you've received with respect to behavior that's gotten you penalized. Do a dedicated review pass only for this, if necessary.
- Give yourself a month or two where you err on the side of not posting.
- In particular, besides keeping to the guidelines, in particular don't comment on downvotes or your penalties.
- Refrain from emailing the mods about your penalties during that period.
- Perhaps use the "delay" so you can give yourself more time to review and perhaps retract a comment before it's made public.
This might all across a bit harsh, but I do think you need to take what you yourself have written to heart and change your behavior if you want to continue posting on HN. And I hope you do! You appear to care deeply about this and are passionate about things you believe in. Those are good things when properly directed. It'd be a shame for you to be banned when it's important to you.
If I was doing something they saw as an act of aggression, the answer isn't to then have a policy of acting aggressively towards me. Shoving my comments to the bottom automatically has certain implications, and it basically removes you from the community and turns the mods into bullies.
And I get that what I did may have warranted some sort of punishment, but at this point it's unclear what precisely triggered this or whether any of what you say is true.
If I deserved to get banned, then they should just ban me so I can move on.
A serious suggestion: for a couple weeks, try evaluating every paragraph you are thinking about posting and deciding whether it is "meta" or not and then just omit the ones that are. See if this makes your HN experience worse.
- Everyone gets to see...
- who does the up/down votes.
- what any moderators' decisions/actions are
- what the algorithms for viewing real estate
- etc.
Some other aspects: - The "forum" (and all inter-user communication) lives on a block chain-like merkle-DAG.
- The real estate algorithms would be customizable, i.e. you have varying views on the same data.
- The "forum" would also act as chat rooms, todo lists, picture galleries, and more...One of the central aspects of HN is that humans control it, and they have good taste. I don't think you can take either of those qualities away without sacrificing what makes HN good.
And part of that implies that any HN competitor needs to have those qualities in abundance – which means allowing them to wield real power, and not being constantly second-guessed by the community.
It's a tradeoff, and it's the "good king" problem. You want someone in power who wants to do the right thing, and who is capable of doing it well. But that's extremely rare.
Dan is close, and we're all lucky to have him. Scott is a close second. But their weakness is that they don't really participate on HN anymore. Neither of them post here, and we don't get to feel connected with them like we felt with pg in the early days.
I think I'm not alone in missing that connection. So my theory is that if another site springs up with similar characteristics to HN, but with actual humans running it – people you can actually strike up a conversation with – then those who are interested in good conversation will flock to it.
That requires being capable of executing that plan, which is the tricky part.
> One of the central aspects of HN is that humans control it, and they have good taste. I don't think you can take either of those qualities away without sacrificing what makes HN good.
What if the user could "control it", i.e. could pick and choose algorithms of how to present views of the same data? Since everything is in the light, you could also share these algorithms - just like you share a collection of browser extensions or editor color schemes, etc. So you could have the "HN algorithm" which has the characteristics you mentioned with the slow-ban, and upvote/downvotes.
Heavily weight certain user's tags (think of voting up/down in terms of raw tags, and the repercussions of voting as an interpretation of those tags). These users would be who "HN" is - in this case the two that you're mentioning. You could also incorporate AI/ML opinions: Sentiment Analyzer A/B/../N, Some Other ML Analyzer, Bob's Analyzer. The main thing is that you have a way of associating identities with opinions, and then creating a projection algorithm that projects stories based on those identities and opinions.
So interestingly, it would be humans running the platform, but enabling each individual user to create his/her own projection algorithms.
> I think I'm not alone in missing that connection. So my theory is that if another site springs up with similar characteristics to HN, but with actual humans running it – people you can actually strike up a conversation with – then those who are interested in good conversation will flock to it.
At some point, won't the volume of interaction with any individual human exceed the ability of that person to respond? Won't the mentions, responses, etc. eventually be too much to handle? Also, isn't the up/down voting what determines in this site what the definition of what the "good" in "good conversation" is?
> That requires being capable of executing that plan, which is the tricky part.
Darn skippy. The characteristics I mentioned above I've already got well grounded with ibGib and it's taken quite awhile. It's a merkle DAG-based open-data design that I've created. Only I didn't create it to be a blockchain, as I didn't know how blockchains worked and was only vaguely aware of Bitcoin's existence. I created it to be a distributed microservice architecture (again, I didn't know the term microservice...I came up with "autonomous service" 15 years ago - still have the whiteboard). I wanted a SuperMemo-like learning algorithm, but the ability to have all of the aspects of the algorithm measurable (not an easy thing), to maximize the learning process. I've been shaving the yak ever since and it turns out to be like some understand blockchain graph data stores to act.
But if you game out the implications of this, the conclusion is that everyone will see a different front page. And that has a bunch of subtle implications.
Reddit tried it. It could work. But it makes for a divided community, or set of communities. You see this with the various subreddit wars.
Do you have an email I can chat with you more about this? Hit me up if you're interested.
https://www.ibgib.com/as-chat/pic%5E6F40CA17107671491E64DB0B...
I've started to respond a little bit to your conclusion of seeing different front pages. Note that the site seems to be a little slow at the moment (I'm not much of an optimized coder, as the underlying tech is hard enough - premature optimization and all that).
I'm a bit busy tonight with hacking, but I'll keep the tab open and check it periodically.
And it's especially slow today - not seen it like this before. Barely possible I'm hitting the extent of my small instance's capabilities.
It was intentional. I would love to write more comments like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7602457, but as of now there's no incentive. Exponentially less people see comments at the bottom, because everyone uses the [-] collapse button now to navigate between topics. Why would I spend 30 minutes (or sometimes an hour, it's a fun hobby) to write a good comment when it's simply pinned where <5% of people will see it after an hour or so?
My penalty stemmed from writing https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15884820. Some sort of penalty may have been warranted. HN probably isn't the proper place for that kind of discussion.
But they reacted – I think – by visiting https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15884400 and adjusting my "gravity" until that comment was near the bottom, or halfway down. And since that comment had ~20 upvotes, that means anything I write with less than 20 upvotes has absolutely no hope of getting anywhere near the top. Meaning it won't even gather any steam anymore.
Not only that, but I was originally slowbanned as well. There's a certain penalty that the mods use to discourage certain types of authors, where you can't post more than 5 comments every 3 hours. This is totally undocumented and took much experimentation to even figure out that's what the specific limit is. Imagine going to a bar and being able to only say 5 things every 3 hours.
Meanwhile I counted ~23 tptacek comments within a span of <2 hours. ~13 jacqusm comments within 3 hours. Etc. So I suddenly felt like I couldn't even respond to people anymore.
I sent a bunch of emails (often angry ones) to [email protected], and I don't blame them for basically writing me off and ignoring them. What incentive do they have to bother with one specific person? So I see their side of it too.
But I'm worried this is a trend. I used to periodically see hellbanned commenters complain about HN censorship and that they were excluded specifically for their politics. And I thought that was fine, and they should be. Their hellbanned comments certainly made it seem like HN would be better off without them. Good mods!
But I see now why people write like that after being penalized. You just sort of... Give up. What's the point in writing quality when no one will see it? There's no competition anymore, no fun. And it sucks that someone in the world with power decided that you, specifically, suck, and suck enough to merit exclusion.
I miss yummyfajitas. The mods made him feel unwelcome at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14116601 and talked down at him https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14124379. And I don't really blame him for leaving. When it feels like the whole community wants something other than what you want, you migrate communities. I wonder where he's at now... Wherever it is, it's probably interesting.
FWIW I've been careful to frame all of this as fairly as possible. And in the spirit of fairness, here are the responses I received:
I took the rate limit back off. I put it on a few days ago because the subthread starting at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15884820 was problematic. You're not solely responsible for that but commenters who create the initial conditions for these things carry more responsibility than the others, since the seeds of the problem are nearly always present in the initial conditions.
It's not a great idea to barrage us with emails because there's a lot Scott and I need to take care of and often we're just under load. As a good programmer you know what sending many messages into a system under load does. In addition to that, it makes us less rather than more interested in replying to you, because it feels like it would be unfair to the other emails who respect normal channels. I'm not saying this because it's in any way personal, just reporting how the dynamics work, since you said you find more information helpful.
Daniel
--
When I asked why this is fair or whether they simply don't like me,
You’re close. A lingering issue with your comments is that they can be more personal than the medium affords. When you’re writing to a large group of people on the internet, they’re not going to hear you in the way that people need to be heard. That needs to come from somewhere else. They’ll only be able to approach what you say from the group’s shared reality, and gaps get filled in with whatever’s going on in the reader. This is what dissolves discourse, and what we need to prevent on Hacker News. It’s why we say ‘substantive’.
Warmly,
Scott
--
Now, I'm pretty sure I'm just an idiot, but I have no idea what this means. All of this could have been avoided by simply saying "Hey, your comments on this topic are kind of annoying and not really a good fit for HN. Could you knock it off?"
I'd be like oh yeah, you're right, that makes sense. Sorry.
But no, apparently people are "not hearing me in the way people need to be heard."
So... shrug. Whatever. There are better things to worry about anyway. And really, I don't matter much, and neither did yummyfajitas. HN will go along fine without us. But it sucks to be sidelined.
The thing is, it was fun to write for HN, and to compete here. It was fun to have my ideas challenged and to find out I was mistaken. That's the whole point! There's no better place to figure out the truth.
But apparently mistakes are not allowed, and the response to making a mistake is to be gaslighted by putting your comments at the bottom without telling you and slowbanning you without warning until you just give up and stop coming back. I sent two more emails and got no reply.
I can only imagine how hard their job is. HN has exploded in popularity, and Dan and Scott are probably the only two people who are allowed to have access to [email protected]. The emails sent to that address can be extremely sensitive at times. But that means it's a big scaling problem: judgements have to be swift, correct, fair, and balanced. And even at five minutes per email, they are probably spammed with a hundred emails every week. That adds up.
So yeah, I get why this happened. Really. I'm not really trying to make a fuss or complain much. This is just pent-up energy from missing HN. I've been on this site since I was 18, and it felt like a second home. Being "marked" as inferior by someone you respect is disheartening.