Re:Ethereum Foundation Releases Alpha Casper Proof of Stake ...
by konschubert on Sunday December 31, 2017 @05:36PM
(#16043416)
> Ultimately, the community of users and businesses at large decides. Cryptocurrencies are social contracts that are encoded in software. If everyone agrees that a rule should change, and updates their software in concert, then the rule de-facto changes.
That's called a chain split, isn't it? Usually there are people who follow the new protocol and people who follow the old protocol, so the currency splits into two.
Bitcoin Cash is an example.
Re:Ethereum Foundation Releases Alpha Casper Proof of Stake ...
by RoboTeddy on Sunday December 31, 2017 @05:42PM
(#16043443)
If everyone updates, then there isn't a longstanding chain split (e.g. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Value_overflow_incident).
But yeah if there's longstanding disagreement, there are two ways for it to go:
* Peaceable fork with replay protection, like Bitcoin Cash
* Fork that seriously fights for the same brand/userbase --- we haven't seen one of these in Bitcoin. Segwit2x would've worked that way, but was canceled
Re:Ethereum Foundation Releases Alpha Casper Proof of Stake ...
by masterjack on Sunday December 31, 2017 @07:18PM
(#16043832)
Actually that’s an example of a soft fork. When you change the rules to make them more restrictive (add limits, decrease block size, block addresses, etc) those running the old version will find the new blocks valid so will try to build on them and find their blocks to be rejected, but can keep running no problem and are incentivized to upgrade.
When you change the rules to be less restrictive (add operations, increase block size, etc) then any old version will reject the new blocks, so will keep running their own chain until they are upgraded, potentially forever if there’s demand.
Ultimately, the community of users and businesses at large decides. Cryptocurrencies are social contracts that are encoded in software. If everyone agrees that a rule should change, and updates their software in concert, then the rule de-facto changes.
In the absence of total agreement, the decision is made by whoever wins the political fight for user/business mindshare. It's also possible for the question to be answered two different ways (a longstanding fork occurs).