USSR + communist china + North Korea + Communist countries in Europe + Cuba + communist countries in Africa. They kind of blow that ideal-neutral theory out of the water
I disagree with the premise, but for the sake of argument, even if taken as assumption the point still stands. "Taxing the rich" is a proposition that will help the people that collect the tax far more than the general population.
A simple example of this can be Seattle and San Francisco Governments, that have had explosive tax income booms, most of their staff collection 6 figure salaries, and yet both cities enjoy very large homeless populations.
Increasing tax income does not mean inequality will decrease. It might even make it worse.
Your argument is completely incoherent. Are you suggesting that raising taxes on the rich through closing loopholes, raising capital gains tax, removing 529 and housing subsidies, and yes, increasing income tax, would actually end up with Gini inequality getting even more skewed?
Absurd.
I didn't turn anything: they are the same thing more often than not.
> Your argument is completely incoherent. Are you suggesting that raising taxes on the rich through closing loopholes, raising capital gains tax, removing 529 and housing subsidies, and yes, increasing income tax, would actually end up with Gini inequality getting even more skewed?
And thus my examples of Seattle and San Francisco: cities that have had exponential tax income at the same time as a net increase in homelessness. + TAX + (extreme?)Poverty simultaneously. It is disproven constantly that what the state gathers, it does not distribute appropriately.
The city of san francisco spends 20k+ a year per homeless person, but if you look at the way they live, you can be pretty certain they don't get that.
Raising taxes is not the solution to poverty. Specially when everybody pays them.
https://www.seattle.gov/financedepartment/documents/Economic...
https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/podcast-h...
Thats seattle. I have limited anecdotal data of seattle, but the homelessness is pretty pervasive, almost San Francisco Level.
On SF:
http://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/S-F-spends-record...
Googling has reports on SF tax revenue, but dont have a quick link for it. It will definitely show growth in the past decade, since there are more people, more consumption, housing boom (and hence prop taxes) etc. If you insist I can google more, but I dont have a skill you dont on that front.
Two of the fastest growing cities ever, tax revenue surge, increased government expenditure, higher homelessness.
Cant help but think that Henry George was right.
Provide me with data that shows that both 1) and 2) are not the case.
Your second link is just a big "data dump" and doesn't point me to the relevant facts, so I'll just share what I saw out of it: tax revenue is growing, even though tax rates aren't being increased. So, amongst other factors, this is likely due to population growth. This actually makes the opposite point of what you want to make.
Your third link does nothing to connect the homeless problem to the increases in tax rate. Show me that homelenessness spikes each time tax rates are increased. It's really a pretty simple graph I am asking for.
You provided no evidence for other points I raised, and the evidence you did provide were for mostly for questions I did not ask. In my first post, I clarified that I want data that shows cause and effect you claim:
increases in tax rates (not revenue!) => increases in city spending => increases in homelessness
Grade: fail. Off to the gulag with you.
2013: 4.32Billion
2014: 4.72Billion
2015: 5.14Billion
2016: 5:41Billion
2017: 5.71Billion
Tax revenue is increasing enormously.
> Your second link is just a big "data dump" and doesn't point me to the relevant facts, so I'll just share what I saw out of it: tax revenue is growing, even though tax rates aren't being increased. So, amongst other factors, this is likely due to population growth. This actually makes the opposite point of what you want to make.
My point is that increasing taxes is not the way to solve poverty. Increasing tax rates is a proxy to leevying taxes, its not meaning per se. Its not that if you tax 40% you have poverty and if you tax 41% you have equality. What matters is how much money is taking and how much is given from top top bottom.
But lets say we want to talk only in percentages. Its not about the legal increase of rates, its about the effective rate. Seattle gathers most of its income with property taxes, which, even with the tax rules unknown to me, have to have been increasing with the increase of prices of land and properties, I'm confident. To the very least, it shows in the revenue.
> ou provided no evidence for other points I raised, and the evidence you did provide were for mostly for questions I did not ask. In my first post, I clarified that I want data that shows cause and effect you claim:
increases in tax rates (not revenue!) => increases in city spending => increases in homelessness
I did not say that increasing tax rates increases homelessness. I said increasing taxes does not necessarily decrease homelessness. SF and Seattle are examples of increased revenue (and effective rates, considering income and prop taxes respectively) and increasing homelessness.
So to the one that says that a steeper progressive taxation will reduce poverty, I shall answer nay.