Oh no, I don't have anything against the website. It worked 100% of the times I tried in less than one second and it responds well to every lighthouse audit for performance except render-blocking tags. Also the books look amazing.
But the point was all about the look of the site and the defense was that it should behave like an old-time simple barebones website because it looks like one. This is not true.
This website waits to parse a JavaScript file that adds like 5 lines to the bottom of the page. It looks and behaves... unconventionally.
I would personally say the website has it's charm, even if it's a bit dated in design.